8 Best Canned Tomatoes For Pizza Sauce – Canned Tomatoes Review

Sharing is caring!

When making your favorite pizza, one of the significant elements of the pizza is the sauce. You can only make the sauce when you have the right ingredients, and tomatoes are significant.

Although most people in Italy use raw tomatoes to make their sauce, you can also use the canned tomatoes.

Canned tomatoes are today such a common concept that not many people have the right tomatoes for the pizza. The environment is different, and so the tomatoes grow differently.

So if you want the authentic tomatoes that will give you the perfect flavors for the pizza, you should use the canned ones we suggest below.

Types of canned tomatoes

It may be hard to say this is the type of tomatoes to use because you don’t know the content. So in the supermarket, you should expect to have the following types of tomatoes.

Whole peeled tomatoes

The name tells you all about it. They feature whole tomatoes that are fully peeled but left whole and then packed in their tomato juice or tomato puree. So you see, the tomatoes you pack in the puree are less processed and more versatile.

Notice that the tomato purees then will have the cooked flavors. The other thing the brands sometimes do is add calcium chloride to prevent it from turning mushy.

Diced tomatoes

Here you have another set of whole tomatoes that they peel and then set in the machine to dice them. After the dicing then they will keep them in the tomato puree again. But again, you can use the regular tomato sauce.

Unfortunately, some people still want to use calcium chloride to stop the mashing up, but the tomatoes get too firm.

Crushed tomatoes

This one has no standard as to how it should look. So the crushed tomatoes can be anything from chunky mash tomatoes to smooth tomato puree. So then, if you want the chunks, it’s better to buy the whole one and then make them into chunks by yourself.

Tomato puree

It features the cooked tomatoes, so you will have it being flavored, but they also strain it to make sure it’s smooth.

Tomato sauce

It features the use of real tomato juice. So then they will cook the tomatoes, and then they strain out the large tomatoes. Next, you can take it back to the heat to cook to a 76% level—notice that the tomatoes will add the strong umami to your pizza or meal.

Tomatoes and Tomatoes sauce

The best-canned tomatoes for pizza

1. Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes, 28 oz, 6 pack.

Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes, 28 oz, 6 pack

View on Amazon

Whoever likes canned tomatoes will have at one point come across this favorite. When you try the tomatoes, I’m sure you will never get enough of them. They have a rich aroma, bright color, and natural taste. No wonder they feature it in many publications.

Most people like it for its authenticity. You will have the perfect tomato flavors for your pizza. It contains a pinch of salt, basil, and whole peeled tomatoes. So then, if you want the natural product with a burst of flavors, this is what you should have.

The basil they then add to each can makes it an ideal solution for the pasta and pizza sauce or even the accompaniment. But that’s not to say that they will not work with other meals because it does.

You see, the whole tomatoes have a firm texture for you only to break it to your desired shapes. Again if you want it whole still, you will notice that it becomes chunky.

I would say buy these best tomatoes since you can get a balance of sweetness and acidity. I particularly enjoy the tomato flavors the most. I also find it ideal to use on my pizza recipes.

Notice that we like the deep red color of the tomato and the slightly thick puree tomatoes. You again have the rich textured food with the velvety sauce.


  • It often also has basil.
  • They have the three ingredients to maintain authenticity.
  • It contains no chemicals nor pesticides.
  • It further has no sugar or other preservatives.


  • It has a firmer texture that means it will retain the chunkiness.

2. San Marzano Whole Peeled Tomatoes, 28 Ounce (Pack of 6)

San Marzano Whole Peeled Tomatoes, 28 Ounce (Pack of 6)

View on Amazon

One of the most preferred tomatoes across the board is the San Marzano. The tomatoes they use to make the pizza meal. Notice that the tomatoes are often firmer but not mushy. I like that you can eat the combination while raw and still have the most delicious meal.

It will make it easy to attain a good mouth texture. Notice that you could decide to eat this on its own without really cooking it. Remember, the SMT doesn’t contain basil.

Now, this is not the same san Marzano imported from Italy. But still, I must say it’s a great choice to use in your different meals of choice.

With this, you will attain the perfect taste and texture. You can add it to any meal to attain a tasty dish. If not for anything, you will like the taste of the tomatoes but also the textures. Although it’s not the authentic one, it will deliver the perfect taste for your favorite pizza.

There’s a reason why the people like to use the same name as the authentic san Marzano one from Italy. They say the tomatoes are the greatest to use on your pizza. These tomatoes were first founded in Naples, Italy. You will like these tomatoes because of the richly sweet, flavorful, and delicious sauces.

Notice, though, that you will have the thicker consistency tomatoes. This one is made in America, though, and it matches the perfect tastes.


  • It’s versatile to use with other pasta and pizza sauces.
  • It’s rich flavorful but with the perfect and delicious acidity level.
  • This one is keto-friendly, gluten-free, and paleo-friendly.


  • Don’t confuse these two; it’s not san Marzano. It’s an American style of tomatoes.

3. Cento Plum Tomatoes

Cento Plum Tomatoes, 28-Ounce Cans (Pack of 12)

View on Amazon

Here you will pack the tomatoes in the tomato juices. We are talking about real tomatoes that are harvested in the vine. The most vital part is that they pick it when it’s ready and ripe to ensure you simply store them in their raw form. Notice that these tomatoes also have a delicate texture where they will even fall apart quickly.

Most people enjoy the peeled tomatoes for their velvety taste. You will like its earthy, bright texture. In most cases, then you will have the canned tomatoes containing the basil, remember.

So you will like its authenticity, primarily since it uses citric acid more than it does use salt. It will make the preservation an easy process. Remember, these tomatoes will also preserve your tomato fruit flavors.

You have the guarantee of fresh tomatoes to use, especially since they just grow naturally. So then you can be sure you have premium quality tomatoes. When you’re buying the tomatoes from this brand, you can be sure you have the perfect tomatoes.


  • You are getting an almost natural style of tomatoes.
  • You will like its original texture and tastes too.
  • It’s delicious and versatile to use with your pizza and pasta too.


  • Some clients complain about the denting of the cans.

4. Muir Glen Organic Diced Tomatoes San Marzano Style with Basil and Garlic

Muir Glen Organic Diced Tomatoes San Marzano Style With Basil and Garlic 14.5 oz

View on Amazon

Another one of the best-canned tomatoes is the Muir glen. So if you need the whole and diced tomatoes, then this is the best choice to use. You will have it seasoned in sea salt. There’s a reason why people like such tomatoes, they are healthy with the perfect nutrients. You see, the tomato’s skin is rich in vitamins and minerals.

Most canning companies will tend to peel off the tomato skin, just as rich in nutrients. Lucky for you, when you buy from the Muir glen, then you are sure to have the richly flavored but also nutritious tomatoes.

Notice, though, that the tomatoes here are ready to use since they fire, roast them, and then dice them. It will make your work easy when you are out making the sauce. So then they will make sure they package the fresh from the farm tomatoes. Within the 8 hours of picking the tomatoes then you will have the company already dicing the tomatoes.

So notice that these cans are BPA-free, and also they are going to be BPA free and without the sugar or any other preservative.

Notice, though, that the cans have lower water content, thus more of the tomatoes. This then means that you will have even more tomatoes. Mind you; they use the tomatoes that they grow in san Joaquin valley.


  • They don’t contain any more added sugar.
  • Here you have a non-GMO product.
  • USDA certified organic.
  • They are full of flavor


  • It’s versatile to use with the different meals.


  • You have other chunks being large.

5. Stanislaus Alta Cucina Whole Tomatoes

Stanislaus Alta Cucina Whole Tomatoes, 6.43 Pound

View on Amazon

Most people who like to visit the Italian restaurants in America are entirely possible you have tasted these tomatoes. It’s the most common option in the market. Most Italian chefs like to use these canned tomatoes.

Some chefs using them for the sauce, while others use them as a part of the toppings. They always pluck the tomatoes from California’s vineyards. You will like them the most because they grow the tomatoes without the need for chemicals. This makes it the most natural style of tomatoes.

You will like the seasonings they do, mainly because it means they have the tomatoes with the fresh basil. So then they will make the sauce delicious and aromatic. They also add the tangy tomato juice to the cans to make it even more delicious.

With this, then you’re sure they won’t add water; thus, you’re getting the enriched tomatoes. So then it will mean that they make the tomatoes rich and lovely.


  • It’s richly flavored.
  • It never has artificial preservatives.
  • It’s versatile; you can use it for the soups sauce and your favorite pizzas and pasta.
  • So then this is an excellent choice of the sauce because it remains tender and soft too.


  • Not all the tomatoes you find in the can are the same size and hardness. Some will be smaller, others harder.

6. Colavita Italian Diced Tomatoes

Colavita Italian Diced Tomatoes, Tetra Recart Box, Eco-Friendly, Sustainable (Pack of 16)

View on Amazon

This is not the typical canned style of the tomatoes because they package them in the tetra packaging. You will attain the safe food standard when you use this style of tomatoes. Also, you will mostly like it for the fact that they contain unique characteristics.

You have the one with the fresh but also natural products. Even though they package them in the paper tetra box, they notice that it will not taste the paper.

One of the most common things you will notice is that the flavors and the vibrant colors mostly influence Italian cuisine. It will help you attain the deep flavors as you enjoy global popularity.

If you use the diced tomatoes on your pizza, you will develop the perfect flavors for your delicious pizzas. If you want it to attain the perfect textures, then you should use this type of tomato. It will last longer if you refrigerate it.


  • Most people enjoy the rich flavors.
  • This one is free of preservatives.
  • Whether you want to use it for soups or sauces, you will notice that it’s a perfect choice.


  • It may have inconsistent flavors.

7. DeLallo Imported San Marzano Whole Peeled Tomatoes

DeLallo Imported San Marzano Whole Peeled Tomatoes, 28-Ounce Cans (Pack of 6)

View on Amazon

Are you looking for something uniquely different? You should choose this tomato style. I know this is a versatile choice that you may use for different needs, including the pizza sauce.

The tomatoes they like to use, though, are on the sweeter side. So then most people, when making the sauce, will add on other ingredients to make it blend well with the sauce you are choosing.

When you want to attain the taste of Italy, then you should choose the tomatoes. The tomatoes they use, in this case, are grown in Italy, and they will also package the tins in Italy. You will realize that it attains the bittersweet taste. It will work great when you pair it with different pasta dishes.

Notice too that they will add on some fresh basil to attain the perfect tastes. This tomato then works best when you’re using it for your soups, sauces, and all other kinds of meals. The problem with most of the tomatoes is that they always have more water.

This type of canned tomatoes, though, will serve you right because it has no watery tomatoes. Even better is the fact that it contains no seeds.


· It blends well with most of your sauces and pasta too.

· If you like the ones from Italy, then this is yours to use or go with.

· You will have it coming in six-packs.


· Some of the cans you therefore use and contain tomato leaves.

8. Tuttorosso Crushed Tomatoes with Basil, Gluten-Free and Vegetarian Recipe

Tuttorosso Crushed Tomatoes with Basil, Gluten Free and Vegetarian Recipe, 28 Ounce Cans, 12-Pack

View on Amazon

This is another one of the most common choices you use in making pizza sauces too. If you are going to use it in the sauce and don’t mind the crushed option, then this is for you to use. I only know one brand of tomatoes when you are looking for the crushed tomatoes. Notice that these tomatoes are not only great tasting; they will also be of great texture.

Since we are talking about the tomatoes already thoroughly crushed, it will take a shorter time to blend them in. This means it will take a lesser time to prep the sauce, unlike when you’re using the other types.

I know this is the kind of tomatoes you will even use as salads or just veggies. Therefore, you don’t even need to cook it as it’s ready for you to consume it as it is. The basil and salt will make the perfect addition to the different meals, yet it’s even a tasty choice. Notice that you will have it work whether you will use it in the pasta or pizza sauce.

Notice too that you can use them directly on your pizza as the toppings. It’s such a versatile choice that you may use to attain the perfect and yet delicious pizza.


· Here you will have the pack of six pieces.

· It will then deliver the best in saving time and effort.

· It contains no preservatives but never even fats.

· It’s a versatile choice that you may use with different meals.


· You will realize that the tins may already be dented.

What makes the canned tomatoes we chose to stand out?

We prefer to check the ones that will work efficiently for the different people using it and most of all it’s comfortable to use.

Also, take the time to check the ingredients and the labels of the allergens and any other things it may contain.

You should check for the additional.

I should mention that the cans with additional flavor will not make such authentic sauce. You are always looking for the ingredients that make it even more delicious.

Take the time to check the list of ingredients in the can. Remember they will have salt, sugar sometimes citric, among others. Remember though; the citric is to sustain the shelf life of the canned tomatoes.

If you are concerned about the product you will use, you should know that it should be as close to nature as you want it to.

Notice that it will work correctly if it’s going to enhance the natural tastes you already have.

The type of tomatoes

Remember, as we had mentioned already, the tomatoes come in different styles. You, therefore, have to choose the one you would like to work with. You see, the tomatoes can be pieced, diced, crushed, mashed, or even just peeled.

When you’re going to use it for the pizza sauce, I believe the whole tomatoes will work best. You will then let it cook over long hours to make the sauce into the texture you’d like to make it to.

In the end, you don’t want to make the watery sauce, so you will need to check the kind of tomatoes you are going for.

The variety of the tomato you then choose will matter.

Again in the list of types, we may have already mentioned this. There are different kinds of tomatoes in the world. The most common one is the san Marzano from Italy. Notice that it’s not the ones you find here in America, though.

One good thing about Italy’s tomatoes is that they are rich in color, flavor, and juices. Remember, the environment in which you make them is quite different, which is why you’ll like it the most.

Confirm the certification

You’ll always want the tomatoes to be natural and, as such, confirms that they indicate the tomatoes as the organic options. You are not going to look for any certification, preferably the USDA type of certification.

With this, then you’re sure to confirm that it doesn’t contain GMO tomatoes.

The nutrients

If you know how to read the nutrient levels, then you will find this to serve you best. You should make sure you know the value of nutrients you will get from using it. Read such pointers from the package. You shouldn’t just take any canned tomatoes, preferably the ones with high levels of nutrients. ‘

Most people like the san Marzano tomatoes more because it’s what the Italian law advises you to use for your pizza. In most cases, it may not even be the real san Marzano tomatoes, so you will need to read a little carefully.

If it has the same name, it should also show you that the tomatoes grew and were harvested in Italy.

And now you know which one are you going to buy. If you are a fan of these canned tomatoes already comment below to tell us what can you use.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment