Pizza is one meal that you can find in one or two restaurants or even more in every city. Yes, it is that common and loved by a lot of people. There are a lot of pizza joints and restaurants in Columbus that you can find pizza.
Finding a pizza restaurant is not the problem; it is finding a place to serve you right, fantastic pizza. Pizza that will leave you going back for more.
We know you might have a lot of preferences as you choose your pizza.
You might prefer a Neapolitan pizza or a Sicilian pizza; you might prefer a thick crust or a thin crust; you might want to sit out in the restaurant or want to order in at home.
Plus, if you are more health-conscious, you might want a vegan pizza or a gluten-free pizza.
These are some of the preferences that we consider when looking for a new city’s pizza place. Hopefully, this article will bring to you some of the best pizza places that take into consideration all your preferences.
By the end of this writeup, you will know the best place to get a pizza that suits your taste in Columbus.
1. Paulie’s Gee
Location: 1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
Contact: +1 (614) 808-0112
Paulie’s brings New York-Style pizza to Columbus, and they serve fantastic Neapolitan pizzas with a thin and crispy crust that makes you keep eating without feeling like you have eaten much.
It is a comfortable restaurant with excellent prices that you might stick to.
They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner; their menu includes pasta, sub, dessert, and sandwiches.
It is a fantastic place because they use only the finest ingredients, and they do not compromise on quality.
They serve fantastic gourmet pizzas of the best quality. If you are a vegan, you should be glad. This is because there is a wide range of options you could pick from the menu.
They have the dine-in option as well as the delivery option. You can pick which one best works for you at different times.
2. Tommy’s Pizza
Location: 1350 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43221
Contact: +1 (614) 486-2969
This is one of the oldest pizzerias on the block, and it has been in business for over sixty years, and they are showing no sign of slowing down.
If you are a fan of New York-Style pizza, you will love the thin cracker crust that this restaurant offers.
The crust is cut into square shapes, the sauce is flavorful, and they are very generous with their toppings.
Their pepperoni pizza is impressive, the pepperoni pieces are crispy, and there is a generous amount on the pizza, and they are not too spicy.
Another exciting pizza on their menu is the All-The-Way pizza which features vegetarian dishes, sausage, and pepperoni. There is a vegetarian pizza that has mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
You can also order Italian cuisines, which is part of their menu; they have a good beer selection. You could try one of these if you are looking for an alcoholic beverage.
They make reservations which means that you have to call ahead of time to make plans. They also offer excellent and prompt delivery services, and your pizza arrives in a warm, great condition.
3. Dewey’s Pizza
Location: 1327 W 5th Avenue, Columbus, OH 43212
Contact: +1 (614) 487-8282
Their motto states that they take pizza seriously, which is truly evident in every pie’s taste. They take fresh pizza to a whole different level, sourcing for and using only fresh ingredients for their pizzas.
They make their pizzas the old school way, hand-tossed in the air, and the cheese is grated on-site each day to give you that fresh experience.
One amazing pizza you can look out for on their menu is the Bronx Bomber.
This pizza is topped with onion, green pepper, mushroom, black olive, pepperoni, and sausage. It is a bunch of awesomeness that will leave you craving for more.
They also serve calzones, salads, desserts, beer, and other soft drinks.
If you are sensitive to gluten, this restaurant has a menu for you that is gluten-free, and they do their best to avoid cross-contamination.
When ordering, it would be nice to add the extra information about your food being gluten-free; this will help them serve you better.
4. Northstar Café
Location 1: 951 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201. Contact: +1 (614) 298-9999
Location 2: 4241 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214-3049. Contact: +1 614-784-2233
Location 3: 4015 Townsfair Way, Columbus, OH 43219. Contact: +1 (614) 532-5444
Northstar offers you pizzas made with pure and natural ingredients that make their pizza stand out from the rest.
They have three locations in Columbus that you can comfortably walk in and have a good time with their delicious pizzas.
The restaurants have a casual atmosphere and ambiance about them but do not be deceived; their pizzas are baked with perfection and commitment.
They have vegan options on their menu, which is comforting for all vegans because you do not have to look too far.
There is also an option for a gluten-free meal. This is aimed at all those who are sensitive to gluten. Northstar has an inclusive menu and takes the needs of a lot of customers into consideration.
5. Mellow Mushroom Columbus
Location: 2170 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240
Contact: +1 (614) 885-6355
Mellow Mushroom is one pizzeria that you can always count on to deliver amazing mouthwatering pizzas.
This is a popular joint for the locals, their 70’s themed restaurant is fantastic and a comfortable place to be in.
Their delicious and unique ingredients are hard to imitate and clone, making their pizzas stand out from the rest. And with their stone-baked pizzas, you get nothing but crispy and flavorful crusts.
They use only the best ingredients locally sourced to satisfy the locals’ longing, and they care about quality customer service.
The restaurant is family-friendly, and it is an excellent place to have a decent meal with your kids and family.
6. Rubino’s Pizza
Location: 2643 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
Contact: +1 (614) 235-0712
This is undoubtedly one of the best places to grab a pizza if you ever find yourself in the neighborhood. Their crust is thin, crispy and flavorful, and charred on the edges. Their sauce is just the right amount of tasty, and it is cooked with herbs giving you an excellent flavor.
The exciting thing is that they make their own sausages, which means you can count on quality and remain fresh and not overstored. Another unique thing is that they do not shred their cheese; instead, they slice the cheese and place them on the pizza.
Their topping is gotten from fresh ingredients that give your pizza that unique fresh taste. If you do not want a pizza, you can order pasta and salads, and they also serve some Italian cuisine on the menu.
It is a lovely spot to have your lunch and dinner, and by the way, the food price here is reasonably low and affordable. It would help if you tried their Margherita pizza and cheesesteaks; they are amazing. You even get the chance to create your own pasta. It is a decent place that you should try out.
7. JT’s Pizza & Pub
Location: 2390 W Dublin Granville Rd, Columbus, OH 43235
Contact: +1 (614) 718-9110
This is a lively, fun-loving place that you cannot miss out on. Apart from the lovely pizza they serve, they also offer daily food and drinks special, making it easier to have lunch and dinner at a great price. And if you are looking for a lively bar, this is the place to be, they offer live music, big screens to watch sports and you can also host your parties here.
JT’s is recognized in Ohio for serving delicious pizzas, and they have won some awards for their fantastic pizza. They have five flavors of crust that you could pick from and four sauce flavors. This is an excellent way to keep the pizza experience exciting and fun.
If you love wings, you should order from them; they serve some of the best wings in Ohio. You can also get some good beer options to accompany your meal. If you want a smooth experience, you can call ahead of time to make reservations.
8. Pizza Cucinova
Location 1: 1187 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH 43212. Contact: +1 (614) 299-9520
Location 2: 4044 Morse Xing, Columbus, OH 43219. Contact: +1 (614) 337-2227
This is a fantastic restaurant that offers delicious pizzas and even allows you to create yours. Apart from the pizza, they have an Italian menu that could help you as you settle into this comforting atmosphere for a meal.
The restaurant is family-friendly, and it is a pleasant environment to sit out with your kids and loved ones. If you are short on time, then you can order takeaway, which means you can still enjoy the tasty food from the comfort of your home.
They serve made-to-order Neapolitan pizzas cooked in a wood-fired oven that gives an extra smoky flavor to your pizza crust. Their toppings are all chosen from fresh ingredients to give you the fantastic experience that you deserve.
9. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
Location: 1030 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201. Contact: +1 (614) 737-3488
Location 2: 268 S 4th St, Columbus, OH 43215. Contact: +1 (614) 737-3801
Location 3: 457 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215. Contact: +1 (614) 869-0249
If you are looking for a leisure restaurant to have a sumptuous pizza meal, this is the place that should come to mind. First of all, all three locations are super comfy and provide a relaxing environment. Secondly, you get to eat incredible pizza in a nice comfortable restaurant.
They serve an authentic New York-Style pizza with an incredibly thin and crispy crust. The pizza menu is quite diverse; you have the regular pizza. They also have vegan options and healthy pizza options for those with health issues but still crave pizza.
This restaurant is conscious about having a clean environment, making you feel at ease, especially if you are sensitive to dirt. They have a super-fast delivery service that brings your pizza to you in good time without having to wait for ages.
10. Borgata Pizza Café
Location 1: 5701 Parkville St, Columbus, OH 43229. Contact: +1 (614) 891-2345
Location 2: 2285 W Dublin Granville Rd, #113, Worthington, OH 43085. Contact: +1 (614) 396-8758
Borgata’s serves homemade Italian pizzas and specialties, and they serve delicious New York-Style pizzas. The crust is fantastic with the right amount of ingredients, and it is hand-tossed which means that it cooks well. It is not too dry, neither is it too salty or tasteless. It is a flavorful crust that makes you keep eating more than you expected.
You can also enjoy their noodles, meatballs, spaghetti, chicken wings, dessert, and salads. They have excellent gluten-free options on their menu; one amazing gluten-free pizza you can check out is the three-cheese with ricotta, feta, and mozzarella cheese.
Some of their best desserts include the lemon ricotta cake and the cannoli. This is a lovely way to conclude your meal, and the desserts are delicious.
11. Café Napolitana
Location: 40 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Contact: +1 (614) 224-3013
This is a family-owned bar that has been in business for the last twenty-five years. They serve delicious food thanks to the family’s secret ingredients
They specialize in New York-Style Pizzas, and their fantastic marinara sauce gives the pizza a remarkable flavor that cannot be replicated elsewhere. They have a fabulous menu that could help you pick out your lunch and dinner. They also have lunch specials, which means you might get good food at a discounted price.
Their services are excellent and quick, and this place will be better for you if you seem to be in a hurry. If you love a lot of cheese on your pizza, this place will be ideal for you; they are very generous with the amount of cheese they spread on the pies.
12. Villa Nova Ristorante
Location: 5545 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214
Contact: +1 (614) 846-5777
This is one pizza restaurant that is keen on their guest and offering satisfactory services. Their pizza is fantastic, and if you love cheese, they give you more than enough. Their pizza is delicious with the right amount of greasiness.
They offer you authentic Italian meals, which include top-notch delicious pizza. The restaurant is comfortable and casual, and it is the perfect getaway spot for you any time of the day. You should try their grilled chicken and their linguine alfredo; it is one bunch of tasty food.
They have a selection of wine and beer, a perfect way to wash down the tasty meal. They also have an excellent selection of pasta that you could order for a lunch or dinner meal. It would be nice to check their online menu, especially if you want your food to be delivered.
13. Blaze Pizza
Location: 1708 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
Contact: +1 (614) 382-8160
Blaze Pizza is one pizza chain that brings incredible pizza to people wherever they find themselves. They can never go wrong with their pizzas.
First of all, they use the best quality ingredients available to give their customers a good experience. Secondly, they always deliver on time because of the fast mechanism they use to cook their pizzas.
They have pre-designed pizzas or build your own pizza, choosing from the list of ingredients presented to you. This means that if you do not like a pizza on their menu, which I doubt, you still get the chance to build a pizza that will satisfy you better.
It is always nice to see restaurants that give you this option, and I wish you could find it in all pizza restaurants.
Another offer most restaurants do not offer is the gluten-free option. Blaze pizza is sensitive because some of its customers are allergic and sensitive to gluten; that is why they have a gluten-free menu.
You can still enjoy your pizza without missing out. And they take great care to make sure that there is no cross-contamination.
14. MOD Pizza
Location 1: 4784 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43230. Contact: +1 (614) 369-4878
Location 2: 6181 Sawmill Rd, Suite A Columbus, OH 43017. Contact: +1 (614) 356-9717
Location 3: 1310 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240. Contact: +1 (614) 254-6062
This is one of the few pizza chains that makes it a list of one of the best places to grab an excellent pizza. They have a long list of toppings that can help you to build your own pizza.
This is an excellent way of trying out different things at different times. Eating pizza must not be a boring experience; it is something that should be fun and adventurous.
They also serve artisan pizzas and salads; they taste just as good as they look. If you are in a hurry, you could try one of their ten pizza options readily available.
The good thing about this place is that they offer quick service, and you do not have to wait for ages to get what you want.
Their delivery service is super-fast as well; you can check out their menu to see what you want and when you place your order. You would be surprised at how fast they get your pizza to you in good warm condition.
15. Figlio Wood-fired Pizza
Location 1: 1369 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH 43212. Contact: +1 (614) 481-8850
Location 2: 3712 Riverside Dr, Columbus, OH 43221. Contact: +1 (614) 459-6575
This is a lovely warm location to have a delicious wood-fired pizza. Their crust is well cooked with the right smoky flavor.
They use some of the freshest ingredients around, and you can tell this from the fresh taste of every pizza bite you take.
Apart from the fantastic pizza, you will be blown away by the cocktails they offer. They have a list of cocktails and quality wine on the menu to add to your meal.
Their pasta is something you could also try out; they are well garnished and tasty.
It is a lovely atmosphere for a romantic dinner or meal with your partner, and the restaurant is set up in dark red lighting that is just perfect.
Another amazing about this restaurant is its gluten-free and vegetarian menu which is considerable. You have many options to pick from, and you don’t have to eat a bland pizza because of gluten sensitivity or a vegetarian.
16. Yellow Brick Pizza
Location 1: 892 Oak St, Columbus, OH 43205. Contact: +1 (614) 725-5482
Location 2: 245 King Ave, Columbus, OH 43201. Contact: +1 (614) 429-0750
This fantastic spot offers Chicago-style pizza with a flavorful crust and unique toppings. You have the option of building your own pizza from the many ingredients presented to you.
More restaurants need to include this option in their restaurants.
One of their famous pizza is called “Dante Inferno,” which contains ingredients like banana pepper, sausage, green pepper, jalapenos, crushed red pepper, Frank’s Redhot, loaded with mozzarella cheese.
If you are inclined to spicy food, this might be the best pizza for you.
They have a vegan menu for the pizzas and their calzones, so you can follow your diet while eating comfortably. They offer vegan cashew cheese, which is no very common.
If you are sensitive to gluten, your need for a gluten-free menu is also catered for here at Yellow Brick.
Location 1: 1618 Neil Ave, Columbus, OH 43201. Contact: +1 (614) 421-2300
Location 2: 265 W 11th Ave, Columbus, OH 43201. Contact: +1 (614) 421-2300
Any pizza place to survive thirty years of existence knows that they have survived that long only by serving the best pizza.
Adriatico’s has been serving pizza for thirty-eight years, and they do not sell mediocre pizza.
They offer authentic New York-Style pizza that is delicious made with only the best fresh ingredients sourced daily. You can either sit-in in the restaurant or use the tables set outside to enjoy the scenery. Both options are comfortable.
You can also order some excellent sandwiches and pasta. They have a good selection of beers and wine to go with your meal. You can order takeout or have your pizza delivered to you at home.
Traveling to a new place and finding the right place to eat is usually an anxious experience. And our preferences usually play a significant role in our indecision and slowness to try out a new place, which might be horrible.
I am very sure no one loves a terrible eating experience.
The pizza places above offer some of the best pizzas in Columbus, and I am sure one or two of them have what you might be looking for. I hope you have the best experience and you get to enjoy your pizza from these places.