I am sure you might have heard about how much New York-Style pizza is worshipped and praised all over.
It rightly deserves to receive all the accolades and praises; it is one of the best pizza styles you can find worldwide.
In this write-up, we will explore some of the best places where you can enjoy pizza in Manhattan. Yes, you are in the city of great pizza, but it won’t be nice to walk blindly into any restaurant.
This article will bring to you the best places and what makes their pizzas unique and outstanding from the rest.
Contents
- 1 1. Patzeria Perfect Pizza
- 2 2. Artichoke Basille‘s Pizza
- 3 3. Keste Pizza & Veno
- 4 4. Prince Street Pizza
- 5 5. Luzzo‘s
- 6 6. Lil Frankie‘s Pizza
- 7 7. NY Pizza Suprema
- 8 8. Joe‘s Pizza
- 9 9. Angelo‘s Pizza
- 10 10. Famous Original Ray‘s Pizza
- 11 11. Lombardi‘s Pizza
- 12 12. Pizzarte
- 13 13. John’s of Times Square
- 14 14. Nizza
- 15 15. Emily West Village
- 16 16. Marta, Flatiron
- 17 17. Motorino Pizza
- 18 Finally
1. Patzeria Perfect Pizza
- Location: 231 W 46th St, 231 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036
- Contact: +1 (212) 575-7646
- Website
This is a small pizzeria, but the size does not affect the generous slices of pizza that they offer. From their perfect toppings to their amazing crust, everything about this place is just amazing.
They serve authentic Neapolitan pizza with a hand-tossed pizza dough that cooks perfectly and nicely.
Apart from their excellent New York-style thin-crust pizza, you can also order a Sicilian thick crust square pizza that is not short of deliciousness.
They also serve an Italian menu in case you want something more than a pizza.
Their menu is diverse; you have other things on the menu like fries, wings, cheesecake, and meat pies. They have a tasty menu, and it is affordable, nothing too expensive.
They do not have ample space within the restaurant apart from the makeshift tables they have included outside.
They are open for takeout, and they also offer delivery services. And they are quite fast with delivery compared to other pizzerias in town. If you happen to find yourself around this area for lunch or dinner, you should give it a try.
2. Artichoke Basille‘s Pizza
- Location: 321 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003
- Contact: +1 (212) 228-2004
- Website
This is one of the best places you certainly have to visit if you find yourself in Manhattan and you are craving pizza.
They source quality ingredients, and their pizzas are always fresh because of the fresh ingredients.
Even when you have ordered and waiting for it to be delivered to you, you can trust that your pizza will arrive warm and fresh.
They have improved their delivery game, packaging the food so that it will arrive warm and ready to eat.
They serve authentic New York-Style pizzas, with amazingly thin and crispy crusts, and their Sicilian pizza slices are one of a kind and delicious.
You have the opportunity to build your own pizza to your taste and liking. You can also get tasty wings, pasta, and fresh salads here.
You can order takeout for your pizza, or you can use the delivery option that they offer.
It would be nice to check out their menu online to see what they have to offer, then place your order.
3. Keste Pizza & Veno
- Location: 66 Gold St, New York, NY 10038, United States
- Contact: +1 (212) 243-1511
- Website
This fantastic restaurant not only offers you amazing pizza, but they can show you how to make one yourself.
They offer authentic traditional Neapolitan pizzas that you will undoubtedly go back for.
There are about seventy types of Neapolitan pizzas on offer; all of them are the original creation of Mastro Pizzaiuolo, the restaurant’s co-owner.
The fantastic thing is that you can watch your pizza being made from scratch whether you are there in person or ordering from home.
Amazingly, they have eighteen different types of gluten-free pizza. Some restaurants do not even offer you one option, but they have gone the extra mile to offer you a variety of awesomeness.
They use high-quality Italian ingredients and organic products, including flour, cheese, and sauce.
They have a great selection of wine that you could pick from to wash down your pizza meal. It is a beautiful experience to be here.
4. Prince Street Pizza
- Location: 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
- Contact: +1 (212) 966-4100
- Website
This pizzeria serves mouthwatering Neapolitan Styles pizza. A bite into one of their pizzas will undoubtedly make you aware of the quality and fresh ingredients that they use.
This pizza spot is famous for its large generous sizes of pepperoni they use for their pizzas.
Their pizza is so good and famous that they have begun shipping their pizzas around the country.
So if you are a pizza fan of Prince Pizza, you can continue enjoying your pizza even if you are out of New York.
They serve artisan pizzas which are rare to find, plus you get the opportunity to build your pizza the way you want it.
They have a sauce selection list, one being the house marinara sauce made with the traditional fresh tomatoes.
One other sauce available is the vodka sauce made with cream, tomatoes, prosciutto, and vodka.
This is undoubtedly one of a kind.
Pictures of their pizzas have flooded the Instagram scene rightly so because of their big following.
It would be nice to stop by and experience what makes them famous on the social media scene.
5. Luzzo‘s
- Location: 15 Ave B, New York, NY 10003
- Contact: +1 (212) 473-7447
- Website
This is a good restaurant with a pleasing ambiance, and they serve great pizza.
It is one of the best pizza joints that you can find in Manhattan, not only for the pizza but also for the Italian cuisine.
You would love their thin crust, which is tasty and crunchy.
There is nothing crappy about their pizza because they keep it truly authentic and Neapolitan.
We all know the key ingredient in any pizza is the pizza dough; this is what chef Michele Luliano has done.
He has spent a lot of years perfecting the art of making the pizza dough, which gives their pizza an edge over many other places.
You can order takeout if you want. Also, there is an option for you to use the restaurant for a private dinner or party.
It would be nice to call ahead of time to plan with the management.
You can take this opportunity and have that pizza party that you have always dreamed about.
You will get the best services; the waiters are awesome and ready to attend to your needs.
Another fantastic thing about Luzzo’s is that they have built wood-burning oven pizza carts that have been stationed at different parts of the city. So you can have your pizza on the go.
These carts serve Neapolitan pizzas with thin crusts, with two choice toppings which are diavola and Margherita.
This is a beautiful idea of reaching out to many customers who cannot make it to the restaurant.
6. Lil Frankie‘s Pizza
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 19 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003
- Contact: +1 (212) 420-4900
- Website
This is a casual Italian restaurant that offers excellent cuisines, but their pizzas stand out more among all the menu items.
They offer delicious Neapolitan pizza made from wood-fired ovens.
The crust is delicious, and it has the added smoky flavor from the irresistible oven’s heat.
If you love a lot of cheese on your pizza, you should consider this place.
They serve pizzas with a generous spread of cheese on them.
One of their specials is the black-truffle pizza which will leave you craving for more.
Their menu is quite diverse to cater to a lot of customers. Apart from Italian, they also offer other cuisines like European, continental, and caterer.
Their breakfast menu has things like omelets, fried eggs, French toast, patties, pancakes, and grilled cheese.
You can begin a great day with them.
They offer takeout and delivery; go online to make your delivery, and you will have your pizza on your doorstep.
They do not receive credit cash, so you will have to pay for your pizza using cash.
One added advantage is that they offer catering services for parties.
So if you are planning on hosting a pizza party at home, you could let them take care of the cooking.
7. NY Pizza Suprema
- Location: 413 8th Ave, 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001
- Contact: +1 (212) 594-8939
- Website
This restaurant has been on the block for a good number of years. It is not one of the new pizzerias around, and it has withstood the time.
They have maintained the tradition of serving authentic New York-Style pizzas, which has kept them in the competitive pizza market.
They offer New York Sicilian pizza, a deep-dish airy crust, and their signature pizzas are the Margarita pizza and the NYC Round Pizza.
Both pizzas have a generous spread of Pecorino Romano cheese which is imported from Italy.
And the margarita has extra parmesan cheese and EVOO olive oil, both imported from Italy.
Their pizza sauce makes all the difference; it is slightly spicy but not too hot and tasty.
They rely on the quality and fresh ingredients to make their pizza.
For them to have survived for close to fifty years tells you of the quality of their pizzas.
They offer delivery services with a five-mile radius of their restaurant.
It is good to note that they close their delivery services half an hour before closing the restaurant.
The position of this restaurant favors those using the train station.
If you find yourself at the train station in New York, you can always get a quick bite before you embark on your trip.
8. Joe‘s Pizza
- Location: 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014
- Contact: (212) 366-1182
- Website
This restaurant was established about forty-six years ago, and this pizzeria has no intention of slowing down when it comes to serving great pizza.
They serve classic New York-Style pizza by the slice and as a full pie. They also offer a variety of food like sandwiches, pasta, and salads.
It is a famous spot among the locals of the area who have enjoyed the excellent pizza and services offered for years.
They use quality fresh ingredients gotten daily from the farmer’s fresh market.
Also, they make their dough from scratch each day offering you nothing but fresh food.
Their pizzas are stuffed to perfection, and some of their best pizzas you can order are the Margarita or the Sicilian pizza.
Every pizza of theirs is hand-tossed and baked with perfection, their crust is thin and crispy, and you will find a generous amount of cheese.
9. Angelo‘s Pizza
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 1697 Broadway Ste 1, New York, NY 10019
- Contact: +1 (212) 245-8811
- Website
Angelo’s offers perfect pizza and Italian food that will have you craving for more.
To give you a wonderful experience, they select the best raw fresh ingredients they use daily to make their pizzas.
They pride themselves on the fresh ingredients they use to build their pizzas from scratch daily.
It is a great spot to have your lunch or dinner, and the fantastic thing is that they have lunch specials that you could take advantage of.
Apart from their excellent pizzas, you can have pasta, calzones, chicken Parmigiana, and sandwiches.
They use a coal oven for baking; expect nothing less than a fantastic well-cooked pizza crust.
If you do not want to dine in, they have the takeaway option.
You can also order delivery and have it brought to any location of your choice.
Check their online menu and see how much their pizzas will cost you, together with the delivery fee.
10. Famous Original Ray‘s Pizza
- Location: 831 7th Ave, 831 7th Ave, New York, NY 10019
- Contact: +1 (212) 974-9381
- Website
Although this restaurant has been involved in a couple of lawsuits concerning the company’s trademark and name, they have never fallen short in providing good pizzas to their customers.
They offer fresh pizza and delicious Italian cuisine.
You can count on them for a late-hour pizza, you can dine in, or you can order a takeaway, or have it delivered to any destination of your choice.
They have three other locations here in New York. They serve authentic New York thin and crispy crust pizza.
It is a lovely spot to try out if you find yourself in the neighborhood.
11. Lombardi‘s Pizza
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 32 Spring St, New York, NY 10012
- Contact: 212-941-7994
- Website
This pizzeria has a lot of history that might amaze you. Firstly, Lombardi is the first pizzeria in the US, founded in the year 1905.
They have been a big player in the pizza scene, and you have to give the respect for lasting for that long.
Secondly, they popularized the New York-Style pizza, so you know that they offer nothing less than an incredible pizza.
They serve a smoky-crusted coal oven pizza crust that is amazing and tasty.
They top this crust with their fresh whole milk mozzarella, purist tomato sauce, and basil.
You can check out their menu to find out the delicious options that they offer.
If you do not want to sit in, you can order takeaway, and they also offer delivery services for their pizzas.
It would be nice to check their online page to know more about the delivery options.
12. Pizzarte
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 69 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019
- Contact: +1 (212) 247-3936
- Website
Pizzarte is one of those few restaurants that get the best ratings from customers because of the excellent pizza and services. They offer you authentic Italian cuisine and pizza.
This incredible pizza space also doubles as a gallery for Neapolitans artists.
The crust from this restaurant is impressive; it is soft has the nan bread features, the crust edges are crispy, light, and chewy, giving you a wonderful experience.
One of the best options on their menu is the Margherita pizza and the house signature pizza called Pizzarte pizza.
With the beautiful space and atmosphere, this is one excellent place that you could hold a party or private dinner.
All you have to do is call the management ahead of time and inform them of your plans.
The staff here are so lovely and polite, and they are patient in helping you out with your concerns.
13. John’s of Times Square
- Location: 260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
- Contact: +1 (212) 391-7560
- Website
John’s pizzeria is an award-winning pizzeria in New York for serving some of the city’s best pies.
They use a coal-fired oven for their pizzas, which means that the pizza gets ready in less time, and they come out perfect with a smoky flavor.
The building is unique and beautiful, and it is regarded as the biggest pizzeria in the US.
This building was once a Cathedral, built in the 1800s.
It has a serene and comfortable atmosphere that immediately makes you feel at home as you step into the restaurant.
Their pizzas are freshly made from fresh ingredients that they source daily.
Two delicious pizzas on their menu you should try out are the Hawaiian pizza and the Bruschetta; they are amazing.
If you are vegan or sensitive to gluten, they have both vegan options and gluten-free options on their menu, so you are covered.
You can order your pizza with the takeout option, or you can have it delivered to you at home.
The best thing to do is check out their online menu for their pizza prices and what it would cost you for delivery.
14. Nizza
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 630 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036
- Contact: +1 (212) 956-1800
- Website
This has been a particular pizza spot for locals here in Manhattan, and it is also growing in popularity among the tourists who come to visit.
They have fantastic pizza options, and their gourmet pizzas are top-notch.
Their gourmet pizzas are made with the finest ingredients that you can find around.
You should try their classic Margherita pizza and their four cheese and honey pizza.
They also offer authentic Italian cuisine, plus the place is clean, and the atmosphere is cozy.
If you are intolerant to gluten, rejoice because they have an entire gluten-free menu that you could order from.
Their meals are inexpensive, and they have a lunch special.
So, if you are looking for a comfortable place to have lunch at a lower price, you should run to them.
This place works best for those who go to the John Golden Theatre for shows and performances.
This nice pizza spot close by is a way for you to wait for your show, o you could have a meal after the theatre performances.
15. Emily West Village
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 35 Downing St, New York, NY 10014
- Contact: +1 (917) 935-6434
- Website
Emily’s offers amazing pizzas, which they make from quality fresh ingredients sourced locally.
They have a seasonal menu that keeps changing depending on the season, and this helps to bring in a lot of creativity and keep things interesting.
The pizza here is excellent, their thin crust pizza is fantastic, it is not too dry, and it has just the perfect crunchy feel.
They also serve a Detroit-style pizza which is not common here, so it is an added advantage for those interested.
They also serve outstanding burgers; if you are around the area at lunchtime, you might consider having your lunch here.
They have an exciting menu and offer lunch specials.
16. Marta, Flatiron
View this post on Instagram
- Location: 29 E 29th St, New York, NY 10016
- Contact: +1 (212) 651-3800
- Website
Marta restaurant is famous for her thin crackly-crusted pizzas alongside cooked vegetables and family-style roasts, and grilled seafood.
Marta’s has a lovely welcoming atmosphere that you would want to enjoy your meal in.
Pizzas are made with the freshest ingredients, made from scratch every day, so you do not have leftover food.
The big wood-burning oven produces your pizza in no time, offering you a lovely, well-cooked pizza crust with a smoky flavor.
They are available for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. You can call them ahead of time to make reservations which saves you a lot of trouble.
17. Motorino Pizza
- Location: 349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003
- Contact: +1 (212) 777-2644
- Website
Motorino offers you authentic classic Neapolitan pizza. They use the traditional brick oven, which cooks the pizza better and adds an extra flavor to the crust.
They use fresh ingredients, making their pizzas fresh from scratch to give you that fresh fantastic experience.
The crispy crust is topped with gourmet ingredients and vegetables, and they have an incredible list of desserts and salads.
You can order delivery if you want. It would be nice to check out their online menu and details and see what is obtainable.
Finally
Being in a new place and finding the perfect spot to have your favorite meal is one blessing we cannot underrate.
These places offer some of the best pizzas in Manhattan, and if you ever find yourself in this side of town, you know the best places to visit.
