A Guide to Toledo’s Pizza Paradise: The 11 Best Pizzerias

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Toledo, you’re in the right place.

Toledo is home to some of the best restaurants in the country, offering delicious and authentic pizzas that will satisfy your craving for a delicious slice.

From classic New York-style Pizza to Chicago-style Deep Dish pizza, to gourmet toppings and unique crusts, the options are endless.

Whether you’re a local or a tourist, you don’t want to miss out on trying these top-rated restaurants in Toledo.

1. PizzaPapalis

  • Website
  • Address: 519 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43604
  • Phone: (419) 244-7722


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by PizzaPapalis (@pizza_papalis)

Pizza Papalis is a pizza restaurant located in Toledo and Detroit with 5 locations.

PizzaPapalis is known for their Chicago-style Deep Dish pizza with a perfect crust and toppings made from the finest ingredients sourced from across the world.

The crust is made from a special flour blend with more protein and no harmful chemicals, and the cheese is from Wisconsin. The sauce is from Naples, Italy and dates back to 1830.

The pizzas are available for dine-in, outdoor seating, takeout, delivery and curbside pickup.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by PizzaPapalis (@pizza_papalis)

You will love the deep dish pizza for its delicious flavor, well-seasoned sauce, and fresh ingredients. The restaurant has a pleasant and fun atmosphere, friendly staff and is kid-friendly with coloring books and crayons for kids.

The price is higher compared to other pizza places in Toledo, but considered worth it by many customers.

2. ZaZa Wood Fired Pizza &Mediterranean Cuisine

  • Website 
  • Address: 3550 Executive Pkwy, Toledo, OH 43606, United
  • Phone: +1 419-531-2400

ZaZa Wood Fired Pizza places a strong emphasis on using high-quality, authentic ingredients in their pizzas and Mediterranean dishes, which contributes to the unique flavor and quality of their cuisine.

Each pizza is 12 inches, and gluten-free or cauliflower crust options are available for an additional charge.

Some popular pizza choices include Margherita, Capricciosa, Quattro Formaggi, Barbeque Chicken, Vegetriana, and more.

You can also create your own pizza by choosing a homemade sauce, mozzarella cheese, and additional toppings.

The restaurant is vegan-friendly and uses only fresh produce, but there is wheat flour in the cooking area.

I highly recommend the restaurant for its authentic woodfire pizza and upscale flavors.

3. Home Slice Pizza

  • Website
  • Address: 28 S St Clair St, Toledo, OH 43604
  • Phone: (419) 724-7437

Home Slice Pizza

Home Slice Pizza in Toledo is a family-owned pizzeria that focuses on serving high quality New York-style thin crust pizza.

The atmosphere of the restaurant includes a downstairs pizzeria with booth seating and an upstairs bar with tabletop seating.

The staff is friendly and accommodating, and the restaurant offers a good selection of craft beers, imports, and spirits.

I would especially recommend the Ethan Stew Bread, Spinach and Artichoke pizza, and the Potato pizza.

4. Inky’s Italian Foods

  • Website
  • Address: 3945 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH 43612, United
  • Phone: +1 419-476-0500

Inkys Italian Foods

INKY’s Italian Foods is a family-owned and operated restaurant located in Toledo, Ohio, USA.

It was opened in 1957 by brothers Frank and John Incorvaia Sr. and has been serving Italian food for over 60 years.

The restaurant is known for its unchanged appearance and secret family recipes for its pizzas and entrees.

The restaurant has a good selection of menu items and is known for its generous toppings on its pizzas.

The atmosphere is as old school Italian American, with a welcoming and cozy feel.

I would recommend the Italian Cheeseburger and meatlovers pizza.

5. Blaze Pizza

  • Website
  • Address: 3330 Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43606, United
  • Phone: +1 419-463-9274

Blaze Pizza is a fast-casual restaurant that believes in making smart choices for their pizzas, people, and planet. They use real, fresh ingredients and avoid artificial preservatives and chemicals in their food.

People are raving about the fresh and fast-fire’d pizza that is made to order, with a variety of toppings and sauces to choose from.

The quality of the ingredients, eco-friendly packaging, and the option for dairy-free and vegan options are also a plus.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Blaze Pizza (@blazepizza)

The staff at Blaze Pizza are always friendly, helpful, and efficient, making it a great place for dine-in or take-out.

You will appreciate the fast and efficient service and the ability to build your own pizzas to their liking.

In addition, the drinks and desserts, such as the lemonades and brownies, are also a hit.

All in all, Blaze Pizza in Toledo is a great place for everyone to enjoy delicious and fresh pizza.

6. Amie’s Pizza Factory

  • Website
  • Address: 6710 Central Ave #13, Toledo, OH 43617, United States
  • Phone: +1 419-842-8008

Amie’s Pizza Factory is a highly regarded pizza place in Toledo known for its delicious pizza with a sweet marinara sauce, crunchy crust, and a variety of topping options, including specialty pizzas like the “2002 Winner” and Reuben.

The staff is friendly and accommodating, and the establishment is clean. Although Amie’s Pizza Factory doesn’t deliver, it’s worth the effort to pick up the pizza as it’s considered one of the best in town.

7. The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar

  • Website
  • Address: 3115 W Bancroft St, Toledo, OH 43606, United
  • Phone: +1 419-720-1818

I love their delicious pizza, especially their thin crust pizza.

You would appreciated the variety of menu options, including a veggie pizza and other vegetarian options.

Additionally, the restaurant was described as having a nice ambiance, a good beer selection, and friendly service.

The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar menu includes the following pizza;

Pizza Price
Margherita $18.99
Johnny’s Special $23.99
Rocco’s Meat Lovers $24.99
Gracie’s Veggie $23.99
The Roman $21.99
Giavanna’s White $22.99
Spicy Sicilian $23.99
Build Your Own (starting at) $16.99
Gluten-Free Cheese (10″) $14.99
Rocket Pie $19.99

They also offer a gluten-free 10″ cheese pizza for $14.99 and a Rocket Pie for $19.99.

8. Pizza Cat

  • Website
  • Address: 4034 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43606
  • Phone: (419) 214-1640
@keeppizzaweirdWelcome to Pizza Cat Max. Come to eat, stay to party.♬ original sound – Pizza Cat

Pizza Cat is a restaurant that offers unique and wacky toppings and celebrates individuality and creativity in food choices.

You will be happy with the quality of the pizza, the variety of options available, and the friendly and knowledgeable staff.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Pizza Cat (@keeppizzaweird)

The fast turnaround time and availability of vegan options are also appreciated.

Overall, Pizza Cat is a place where people can enjoy a delicious pizza and embrace their own “weird” tastes.

9. Guy’s Pizza

  • Website
  • Address: 2001 Starr Ave, Toledo, OH 43605
  • Phone: (419) 720-1990

Guy’s Pizza is a family-owned and operated business established in 2009 by Guy M. in Toledo, Ohio. The business is based on recipes that Guy’s father used in his pizza establishments from the 1980s, 90s, and early 2000s.

Guy’s Pizza is known for its stone-baked pizzas made with fresh dough, 3 cheese blend, homemade spaghetti sauce, meatballs, Italian dressing, Italian sausage, pizza sauce, and sliced deli meat used in their subs.

The food in Guy’s Pizza has a good flavor, huge portions, and good pricing.

You will be excited about the quality of the ingredients and the overall taste of the pizza.

10. Big Slice Pizzeria Sylvania

  • Website
  • Address: 6636 W Bancroft St #2, Toledo, OH 43615
  • Phone: (419) 214-1104

Big Slice Pizzeria Sylvania is a popular pizzeria in Toledo known for its quality pizzas and a local favorite, Pepperoni Slice.

They offer a range of menu items including soda and have been a Slice partner for 2 years.

They provide curbside pickup, accept credit cards and are active on social media to keep their customers updated.

Get a taste of the local culinary scene with Big Slice Pizzeria Sylvania and enjoy a meal that is both delicious and affordable.

Here are some of the pizzas offered by Big Slice Pizzeria Sylvania with their respective prices:

Big Pie ($17.00)
Sicilian Pie ($18.00)
BBQ Chicken Pie ($20.00)
Big Slice Deluxe Pie ($20.00)
Buffalo Chicken Pie ($20.00)
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie ($20.00)
Chicken Parmesan Pie ($20.00)

They also offer various toppings like Italian sausage, pepperoni, apple-wood smoked bacon, bell peppers, onions, and chicken.

11. Jo-Jo’s Original Pizzeria

  • Website
  • Address: 4336 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43606
  • Phone: (419) 473-1223

Jo Jos Original Pizzeria

In addition to serving great pizza, Jo Jo’s Original Pizzeria in Toledo is a Slice partner and has been serving the local community since 2021. Customers can enjoy a variety of dishes, including pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and side dishes.

The restaurant offers curbside pickup, making it easy to get your meal, and they occasionally offer deals and special offers to make dining more affordable. Payments can be made by credit card.

Leave a Comment