15 Best Pizza In Williamsburg (update 2023)

Williamsburg is a historical city; the city’s architecture and the different tourist sites point you to the rich heritage that the city represents.

It is a perfect place to go with your family for a tourist weekend or a getaway together.

It would be normal to wonder if the town with so much ancient history has a decent place for you to bite into a decent pizza.

You do not have to think far; there rare pizza restaurants that offer some of the best pizzas in the town.

This article will give you some directions on the best restaurants for a good pizza meal with your family and friends.

This will help you visit the city fully armed for what it has to offer.

1. Mellow Mushroom


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Mellow Mushroom (@mellowmushroom)

  • Location: 110 S Henry Street, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 903-4762
  • Website

This excellent pizzeria is located in the heart of Colonial Williamsburg, and Mellow Mushroom would not be new to all those around this historic environment. They serve delicious and fresh stone-baked pizzas.

Mellow Mushroom is family-friendly and suitable for families who are on holiday to Williamsburg.

The services provided here are efficient and customer-oriented.

Mellow Mushroom claims that they are more than just a pizzeria; their institution is a state of mind and a culture.

Here you can find quality hand-crafted pizzas made from fresh ingredients that give your pizza a fresh taste and outlook.

You can also find delicious salads, calzones, and burgers on the menu.

You have the option of building your pizza to your taste. They have gluten-free options also with the opportunity to build your gluten-free pizza.

This means that you have a list of exciting ingredients to pick from, and your pizza does not have to be bland and tasteless.

Their delivery service is perfect and works with time. All you have to do is log onto their online menu and select what you want, then place your order, and you will have your pizza in good time.

This is one place to try out while you are in Williamsburg.

2. Maurizios Ristorante Italiano

  • Location: 264E McLaws Cir, 264E McLaws Circle, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 229-0337
  • Website

Maurizio’s is an exceptional restaurant among the locals in Williamsburg, so you can trust that they have some excellent pizzas to offer.

It is a moderate pizza restaurant, and it is classy and comfortable if you are dining in.

This is the perfect restaurant to go to if you want to have decent Italian cuisine.

You should check out their garlic knots, chicken parmesan on Maurizio’s offers, and their garlic pizza.

They are delicious, and you have no regrets about your time and money.

If you are vegan, you are assured of various choices to pick from, so you can have different vegan pizzas on your visit there.

Also, there are many options on their menu for gluten-free pizzas and side dishes.

This means that you are safe if you are sensitive to gluten.

You can use their out-door seating to enjoy the view, and you can also order takeout or have your pizza delivered to your home.

You don’t have to worry about running out of cash because you can pay with your credit cards, making it more comfortable.

3. Bellisimo Pizza Café

Bellisimo Pizza Cafe

  • Location: 6614 Mooretown Rd Ste C, Williamsburg, VA 23188
  • Contact: +1 (757) 220-3371
  • Website

Bellisimo serves incredible Italian food, and this includes some of the best pizzas in the Williamsburg area.

You can get a hot fresh pizza made with fresh ingredients all at an affordable price that you do not have to break the bank.

The crust Is terrific, delicious, and crunchy as you chew. The toppings are tender, well-cooked, and you can find a generous amount of toppings on your pizza.

You should check out some of their New York Style pizza like the Bronx Bomber, and you will undoubtedly go back for more.

Their garlic knots are impressive, and it is one of the best things they have on the menu.

You can accompany your pizza with some beer options available on their menu.

If you are big on your cheese, you should try some of their cheese pizzas, they are delicious, and the cheese toppings have a generous amount.

Bellissimo has a track of offering good service to customers, and you will be impressed at their efficiency level.

The restaurant atmosphere is peaceful and beautiful ad it is an excellent place to have a meal with your family or friends.

You can order takeaway if you want.

4. Blaze Pizza


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Blaze Pizza (@blazepizza)

  • Location: 5134 Main St, Williamsburg, VA 23188
  • Contact: +1 (757) 255-1949
  • Website

Blaze Pizza is one of those classic pizza joints that never fail on quality.

They have blazing ovens that produce pizzas within three minutes, and the pizzas have some of the finest crusts.

You should try their cauliflower pizza crust; it is a bunch of deliciousness.

They have a vegan option and a keto-friendly crust.

Their pizza toppings are fresh and flavorful; some of the options you could consider are their BBQ Chicken, meat lovers pizza, and their Classic Margherita pizza.

There is a list of veggies you can pick from if you are interested in having a vegan pizza.

If you want quick and friendly service, then this is the ideal restaurant to go to.

They prepare their pizza in good time, and they attend correctly to customers.

You can also order takeout, or you can order from your home and have it delivered to you in good time.

5. Antonio Ristorante Italiano

Antonio Ristorante Italiano

  • Location: 801 Merrimac Trl Ste E, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 258-5300
  • Website

If you are looking for classic Italian meals with a touch of style, this is the right restaurant that you should be heading to.

This will be the best setting for a romantic dinner or a meal with your family where you can get good food and a comfortable space.

Antonio’s offers amazing good pizza, desserts, salads, beer, and wine. Whether you chose to dine in here or order takeout, you can be assured of the quality of your meal.

Their mozzarella sticks are something you can bite on as you wait for your meal; they are delicious and adequately made.

If you have gluten sensitivity, you can feel safe in this restaurant.

They have gluten-free options that you can pick from, and they are serious about cross-contamination.

They do their best to make sure they provide a gluten-free meal.

6. Annas Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Annas Brick Oven (@annasbrickoven_)

  • Location: 2021 Richmond Rd Ste D, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 229-5252
  • Website

What could go wrong with a brick oven pizza? Nothing but awesomeness and a great pizza.

This restaurant serves authentic Italian pizza, and they give you value for your money.

If you are looking for an excellent Italian meal, you can get a good meal here.

Some of the things on their menu include pasta like penne, fettuccine, spaghetti, linguini, and rigatoni.

You can even get a gluten-free capellini pasta if you request in good time.

If you want your pizza gluten free Anna’s offers you this option.

All you have to do is chose from a list of gluten-free ingredients available, and you can eat your pizza comfortably.

You can also have veal, chicken, and some seafood options.

It would be nice to go through their menu and see the varied options that they offer.

If you are looking for an atmosphere to have a private dinner for two or a group, you can book them ahead of time.

They have an appealing and beautiful atmosphere to host private events.

There is a takeout option that you can use when ordering your pizza or pasta.

7. Sals By Victor

Sals By Victor

  • Location: 1242 Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 220-2641
  • Website

Most people will agree with me that this is the best restaurant with Italian cuisine in Virginia.

The quality of the ingredients and the preparation method is topnotch, and the services provided are just exceptional that everything flows effortlessly.

Their New York Style pizzas are amazing, and the crust is thin, crispy, and crunchy as you chew.

Even their gluten-free crust is impressive; even if you are not sensitive to gluten, you will still enjoy this crust.

Their toppings are made from the freshest ingredients, sourced daily.

While eating your pizza, you will not get the feeling that the ingredients have been over-preserved.

You will enjoy nothing but a fresh pizza, all at an affordable price.

You can also get delicious varieties of salads, soups, bread, and seafood to accompany your pizza meal, or you can eat them on their own.

There is an excellent collection of wines on their menu that you could pick from to wash down the delicious pizza and pasta.

They have a comfortable, scenic environment that you could always dine in, or you can order for quick delivery.

They make deliveries within a five-mile radius, and if you order food worth $100 upwards, they deliver within a ten-mile radius.

But to be on the safe side, it would be nice to clarify the delivery technicalities as you make your order.

8. Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta

Olde Towne Pizza Pasta

  • Location: 5540 Olde Towne Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188
  • Contact: +1 (757) 253-7846
  • Website

This is a moderate restaurant that pays a lot of attention to client satisfaction.

They offer freshly made pizzas made from fresh ingredients. It is one of those places that you can comfortably enjoy your Italian meal.

They serve authentic New York-style pizza with a thin, crispy, and delicious crust.

Be sure that you will find fresh ingredients prepared each day, and these ingredients haven’t been kept overnight.

They have daily specials, and they make different sauces to go with these different options.

You can never get bored or tired of the menu down here. They make their eggplant parmesan, chicken parmesan, meatballs; they marinate all their meat, making sure they are flavorful.

They also make their own pizza, tomato sauce, and salad dressings from scratch each day.

Another added advantage to this place is that it can seat many people, so if you plan a party or private dinner, this can be the best atmosphere for you.

If you plan to use the restaurant for a group dinner or meal, it would be nice to inform them ahead of time.

This will help them to prepare and host you better.

9. New York Deli & Pizza

New York Deli Pizza

  • Location: 6546 Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188
  • Contact: +1 (757) 564-9258
  • Website

True to their name, this restaurant offers you authentic New York-Style pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and other meals.

Without a doubt, the meals here are delicious; every bite of your pizza will confirm this.

They are generous with their cheese which you can find all over their pizza.

They use freshly picked tomatoes which makes the pizza sauce tantalizing.

You can get a gluten-free pizza upon request, so it would be nice to call in ahead of time to make your request.

If you do not want to choose a pizza, you can pick their sandwiches.

These sandwiches are stuffed with excellent ingredients, and they are close to forty options that you could pick from.

You can also get some vegan options on the menu if you are vegan.

Apart from the pizzas and sandwiches, another aspect that you will be happy about is their salads.

You could pick from a great variety; there is the Original Greek Salad, Small Greek Salad, combo salad, Julienne salad, and Small combo salad. It is an excellent restaurant to try out while in Williamsburg.

10. Two Sisters Pizzeria

Two Sisters Pizzeria

  • Location: 4506 John Tyler Hwy, Williamsburg 23185
  • Contact: +17572581600
  • Website

You will love this place for their handcrafted pizzas made with mastery and an eye for details.

Every bite of the pizza here tells you the attention given and the use of quality ingredients.

Two Sister’s pizza is tasty, delicious and the flavor stands out from all other pizzerias.

Every pizza is baked fresh in their kitchen, and they make the dough fresh every morning.

This freshness also applies to their ingredients used for the toppings, which gives the pizza a delicious appeal.

Their fast, hot oven makes their pizzas ready in no time. As such, you would not have to wait for ages to have your order.

They offer delivery services as well if you would prefer to have this incredible pizza from the comfort of your home.

11. Jamestown Pie Company

Jamestown Pie Company

  • Location: 1804 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 229-7775
  • Website

This pizzeria gets its name from a part of the area’s history; what a better way to attract customers than name your pizzeria after a historic place.

It is not just about the name, but they are passionate about offering the best services to customers, which they consider part of their extended family.

It is a perfect spot to stop and have a quick meal while making your tourist rounds.

They do not have a sit-in area, but they have provided picnic tables outside for you to enjoy your fantastic pizza.

It is an excellent way to have a good pizza while enjoying the scenery with a lot of history to tell.

They have gourmet pizzas that offer you a fresh taste for your pizza, made from quality and fresh ingredients.

Apart from their pizzas, they serve delicious sandwiches as well.

Other things on the menu include salads, mozzarella sticks, French fries, nutty pies, and different fruit pies.

12. Brickhouse Tavern

Brickhouse Tavern

  • Location: 755 Scotland Street Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: (757) 345-6060
  • Website

This Italian-American restaurant can get some of the best world-class pizzas and other meals such as sandwiches, salads, and pasta.

The atmosphere within this restaurant is comfortable, and you can comfortably organize a family gathering or private dinner for friends in the building.

Brickhouse Tavern is a favorite spot for the locals, especially students of universities around the area.

You will enjoy your New York-Style pizza here and feel like you are in New York.

If you are there for an extended period, you can catch daily happy hour specials, which are excellent.

Their pepperoni pizza is one of a kind, and the aroma sends you drooling all over the place.

This pizza’s crust is thin and crispy, and the pepperoni pieces are also crispy and tasty.

If you are a fan of wings, you should try some of the wings on their menu; you will not regret the decision.

13. Huzzahs Eatery

Huzzahs Eatery

  • Location: 113 Visitor Center Dr, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (800) 447-8679
  • Website

Huzzah’s is a family-friendly restaurant, the type that would have the best atmosphere for kids.

They are not just known for their comfortable space but also their amazing tasty pizza.

They serve made-to-order pizzas, pasta, sandwiches, and burgers that you could enjoy.

Huzzah’s is just next to the Woodlands hotel frequently used by tourists, so it offers you a comfortable arrangement for meals.

You do not have to leave your hotel and go far, neither do you have to wait a long time for the pizza to be delivered to you.

Their crust is impressively made with a wood-fired oven. It is thin, crispy, and has an extra smoky flavor, which makes the crust irresistible.

If you have kids, I am sure they will love this place. Because there is an option for kids to personalize their pizzas, and they can prepare it themselves if they want to. I am sure it should be so much fun.

14. Second Street Bistro

  • Location: 140 Second St, Williamsburg, VA 23185
  • Contact: +1 (757) 220-2286
  • Website

This is a comfortable spot that offers American cuisine to customers.

You can have lunch or dinner over here; they have a comfortable atmosphere for a sit-in or sitting outdoor.

Their impressive list of desserts is something you have to leave a space for while eating.

They have a vegan option on their menu, which many restaurants on this list do not offer.

Also, they have a list of gluten-free pizzas and other food on the menu.

You can comfortably eat here without having to worry about any health issues or complications.

A different thing on the menu is their martinis, cocktails, and their microbrew beer.

These drinks will be an excellent way to wash down your meal and conclude your stay there.

15. Francescos

  • Location: 6524 Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188
  • Contact: +1 (757) 345-0557
  • Website

This is a lovely Italian restaurant to dine in; they offer authentic Sicilian-style pizza that is very delicious.

You should try out their gourmet pizza; they are fresh and made with the best quality ingredients that you can find around.

Some of their gourmet pizzas include Margherita pizza, Caprese pizza, Spinache pizza, Agrigento pizza, White pizza, and the Spincione pizza.

All of them are tasty with a fresh flavor. Some other things on their menu include calzones, Stromboli, subs, dinner appetizers, dinner salads, and dinner pasta dishes.

You can have a dine-in in their restaurant or order takeout, or have it delivered to your home.

They allow the use of credit cash which is an added advantage if you run out of physical cash.


The restaurants on this list offer you the best places to comfortably have a decent pizza meal in Williamsburg.

Some have the best atmosphere if you want a comfortable sitting place, and some can hold more crowd in case you are in a group.

Also, not all the places on the list have vegan and gluten-free options like others. So, it would be nice to check and find the one that best suits your needs and taste.

You can enjoy your trip to Williamsburg and also enjoy the eating experience.

Leave a Comment