Pizza Paradise: Exploring 13 Birmingham’s Must-Try Pizza Joints

There’s no better place to enjoy pizza than Birmingham, Alabama. In the city, you can find delicious pizza places with a variety of toppings, crusts, and flavors.

From classic pepperoni to vegan options, Birmingham’s pizza scene has something for everyone.

There are plenty of options in the city, whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal.

In this article, we’ll take a look at 13 top pizza places in Birmingham and what makes them stand out.

So, if you’re ready to explore the world of pizza in Birmingham, read on!

1. Slice Pizza & Brew

  • Website
  • Address: 725 29th St S, Birmingham, AL 35233
  • Phone: (205) 715-9300

Slice Pizza Brew

Slice Pizza & Brew is a popular pizza spot in Birmingham that serves up delicious, saucy, and savory pizza.

The Bajalieh Special and the Soul Pie are my favorites, and the staff is friendly and accommodating.

You will like the tater tots, garlic bread, and brown butter pasta.

Slice Pizza & Brew offers a variety of pizza options, from their own creations to classic margherita pies, and they never disappoint.

The outdoor seating is great, and parking is easy.

You will be delighted with the fresh and flavorful toppings and the perfectly cooked chicken wings.

Slice Pizza & Brew is a must-try pizza destination in Birmingham.

2. Post Office Pies

  • Website
  • Address: 209 41st St S, Birmingham, AL 35222
  • Phone: (205) 599-9900

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Post Office Pies (@postofficepies)

One of the great places to eat in or carry out, Post Office Pies has a wood-fired oven that churns out amazing pizzas, and their in-house-made crust is thin and flavorful.

I would recommend the white pizza with added chicken, and the seasonal Brussels sprout salad.

You will love the crispy crust and delicious toppings of the pizza.

They also make their own ingredients on site, including the pizza dough and sauces, and their staff is friendly and quick with deliveries.

The food is always fresh and clean, and the restaurant has a decent beer selection.

The ambiance is great, and the bartender is known to make delicious drinks.

3. Pies & Pints – Birmingham, AL

Website

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Pies & Pints (@piesandpints)

Pies & Pints in Birmingham, AL is a highly recommended pizza place with delicious pizza and excellent service.

I would recommend the Cuban Pork pizza, Gorgonzola salad dressing, steak and cheese sandwich, wings, sandwiches, and salads.

The crust is crunchy, and the toppings are always amazing, and the atmosphere is rustic and enjoyable.

Pies & Pints also has a huge selection of beers on tap, and the service is attentive and personable.

4. The Filling Station Bham

  • Website
  • Address: 5524 Crestwood Blvd, Birmingham, AL 35212, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-592-3455

The Filling Station Bham is a unique and cool pizza place located in an old Shell station from the 70s.

They have a great selection of craft beer, a large all-season outdoor dining area, and live music.

The eggplant alfredo pizza is a must-try, and they also offer great happy hour deals, half-off bottles of wine, and Sunday brunch.

The food is delicious, with a thin and light crust and generous toppings.

They also have great sandwiches, beef nachos, and toasted ravioli.

It’s not cheap, but the prices are very reasonable for the amount of food served.

5. Giuseppe’s Cafe

  • Website
  • Address: 925 8th St S, Birmingham, AL 35205
  • Phone: (205) 324-2626

Giuseppe’s Cafe is a small and cozy Italian-American restaurant located in the Gable Square district on the South Side of Birmingham.

The shrimp pesto linguine and meatball sub are highly recommended, as well as the Hawaiian pizza and shrimp alfredo.

The restaurant has a warm atmosphere with a beautiful mural, and the servers are attentive and helpful in recommending dishes and wine.

The dining room is small, which creates an intimate and family-like ambiance.

Giuseppe’s Cafe is a great choice for an authentic Italian-American meal with family vibes.

6. Bettola

  • Website
  • Address: 2930 3rd Ave S, Birmingham, AL 35233, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-731-6499

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Bettola (@bettolabhm)

Bettola is another highly recommended restaurant in Birmingham, with friendly and helpful staff, fresh and delicious high-quality food, and reasonable prices.

The atmosphere is wonderful, and the bartender and service are attentive.

The calamari and pizza are must-tries. Handmade pasta and sauces, unique apps, and cocktails are all sourced fresh.

The Burrata is amazing, and the seasonal dishes are worth trying.

The outdoor setting is pleasant, and the restaurant is within walking distance to Jeni’s ice cream and Lumbar.

7. Area 41 Pizza Co

  • Website
  • Address: 30 Manning Pl, Birmingham, AL 35242
  • Phone: (205) 995-4141

Area 41 Pizza Co in Birmingham is a popular spot for delicious pizza and other Italian cuisines.

The atmosphere is pleasant and the service is friendly and attentive. You can choose to dine indoors or outdoors.

The pizza is a standout dish, with a crispy crust and a range of toppings to choose from.

Other menu items, such as the meatball sub, Caesar salad, and chicken parmesan sandwich with skinny crinkle fries, are also highly recommended.

Sometimes you will experience longer wait times, but it is worth it.

8. Tortugas Pizza

  • Website
  • Address: 2801 John Hawkins Pkwy, Birmingham, AL 35244, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-403-9800

Tortugas Chicago-Style Stuffed Pizza from Alabama News Center on Vimeo.

Tortugas Homemade Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria that has been serving up the best Chicago-style pizza in the South since 1999.

Their pizza has been widely recognized and hailed as Birmingham’s Primo Pizza and the Best Pizza in the Southeast by Turner South’s Blue Ribbon Show.

Tortugas takes pride in using the freshest toppings and cheeses to create their signature Chicago Stuffed pizza, which is made and baked like a pie in a two-inch deep pan and filled to the top with a blend of mozzarella cheeses and fresh toppings.

The dough and sauces are made from scratch, resulting in a unique and delicious pizza experience.

While the stuffed pizza takes around 45 minutes to prepare, it’s worth the wait for every bite.

With a rich history and dedication to their craft, Tortugas Homemade Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Birmingham.

9. Salvatore’s Pizza & Pasta

  • Website
  • Address: 4673 US-280, Birmingham, AL 35242, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-991-2881

Salvatores Pizza Pasta

Salvatore’s Pizza & Pasta is a family-owned Italian restaurant in Vestavia, Alabama.

Their food, which includes homemade sauces and almost 20 different pasta dishes, brings back the aromas and tastes of an era long past.

Salvatore’s has been recognized as having the “Best Lasagna” and “Best Alfredo Sauce” in Birmingham.

In addition to their exceptional food, the restaurant has a warm and welcoming atmosphere, and their service is consistently top-notch.

You would appreciate their fresh ingredients, homemade meatballs, perfect crust, and great customer service.

The restaurant is also family-friendly, with personal-sized pizzas available for kids.

Salvatore’s Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit for anyone in the Birmingham area looking for authentic and delicious Italian food.

10. Mellow Mushroom Birmingham

  • Website
  • Address: 1200 20th St S Ste 100, Birmingham, AL 35205
  • Phone: (205) 212-9420

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Mellow Mushroom (@mellowmushroom)

Mellow Mushroom Birmingham is a casual pizza chain restaurant located in downtown Birmingham.

The decor is funky, and the food is fresh and delicious. The pizza toppings are plentiful, and the staff is friendly and efficient.

I would especially recommend the Pacific Rim pizza and the wings, and also enjoy sitting outside.

You can also choose vegan options.

The restaurant is a great spot for lunch or dinner in the Five Points area with fair prices.

11. De Vinci’s Pizza

  • Website
  • Address: 2707 18th St S, Birmingham, AL 35209, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-879-1455

De Vincis Pizza
De Vinci’s Pizza is a local pizzeria in Birmingham, AL, offering a range of delicious food and excellent service.

They have a variety of mouthwatering pies, including classic cheese pizza and various specialty pizzas such as Hawaiian, Old Master, Mona Lisa, and more.

They also serve different salads, starters, calzones, sandwiches, house specialties, desserts, and provide a kids’ menu.

The atmosphere is quaint and small, with an Italian family feel.

12. Iron City Pizza Company

  • Website
  • Address: 2005 11th Ave S, Birmingham, AL 35205, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-847-4396

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Ironcitypizzaco (@ironcitypizzaco)

Iron City Pizza Company is a local pizzeria located in Birmingham’s 5 Points neighborhood.

They pride themselves on their handmade stone-fired pizzas, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients sourced from local farms.

Chef Dustin Allin makes everything in-house, from the dough and focaccia to the sauces and dressings.

The restaurant offers an excellent view of Highland’s Methodist Church and aims to contribute to the revitalization of the historic 5 Points Southside neighborhood.

Iron City Pizza Company also offers a solid beer selection and interesting pizza options with toppings in great quality and full of flavor.

Other highlights include the cheesy garlic focaccia bread, in-house pickled jalapenos, and unique drinks.

13. Davenport’s Pizza Palace – Mtn Brook

  • Website
  • Address: 2837 Cahaba Rd, Birmingham, AL 35223, United States
  • Phone: +1 205-879-8603

Davenport’s Pizza Palace in Mountain Brook Village offers old-school arcade games, making it a great spot to bring the whole family for a tradition of great pizza and entertainment.

The thin-crust pizza is known for its amazing flavor, which cannot be found anywhere else in Alabama.

Although the cost and wait times can be a bit high, the quality of the pizza makes it worth it.

The menu is simple but fresh and tasty, with freshly chopped veggies.

The service is friendly, and the atmosphere is clean and quaint.

Final thoughts

Birmingham, Alabama is a pizza lover’s paradise, with many restaurants offering delicious pies.

The variety of toppings, crusts, and flavors is impressive, from classic pepperoni to vegan options.

In addition to the 13 pizza places listed here, there are many more in the city.

Pizza in Birmingham has something for everyone, whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal.

Are there any pizza restaurants I missed? Let me know in the comment.

Leave a Comment