15 Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce Of 2022- Canned Pizza Sauce Reviews

When you visit any supermarket or grocery store, you will realize that there are very many brands of pizza sauces claiming to be the best.

Out of curiosity, I decided to try cooking pizza. Buying all the other pizza ingredients was easy except the sauce.

Of course, I ended up with a good sauce, made my pizza but after that, I came across a list of other options that I would have used.

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce
  • PREPPED: Pizza sauce made with delicious tomatoes, seasoned lightly with a dash of sea salt, oregano and more
  • MADE WITH ORGANIC TOMATOES: USDA Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified
  • EASY MEAL ADDITION: Store canned organic pizza sauce in the pantry for soups, stews and pizza

The article is going to walk you through the various sauces in the market and the best one to pick.

Most pizza sauces are usually a blend of tomatoes and Italian seasoning. There are various brands in the market today though. Check below.


image: Slice Pizzeria

Here is the best pizza sauce to buy.

1. Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce, 15 oz. (Pack of 12)

View on Amazon

This is a taste of goodness. It’s simply made using whole tomatoes which are cooked into a thick sauce. The tomatoes used are rich and vine-ripened. They are also harvested when they reach the peak of their flavor.

The company then uses the Italian 7 herbs for seasoning the tomatoes and the extra virgin oil helps to derive a delicious taste. The taste is also a product of the organic tomatoes from the farm. Be informed that this sauce has no additives in form of sugar.

This makes it a high-quality product and full of flavors. Since it has enough herbs to enrich your pizza, you don’t need to add more spices as it’s spiced already.

Now you know that you can make a quick late-night pizza all you need is Muir glen and you are good to go. The sauce is smooth and contains mild herbs that even children can enjoy.

2. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

No products found.

No products found.

This sauce is more than half a century old and it’s still growing strong. Don peppino like Muir glen is made using vine-ripened tomatoes. Additionally, it contains corn oil, salt spices, and garlic. This is basically a family brand that will never fail you.

I have a friend that doesn’t trust any other sauce apart from don peppino when making her homemade pizza. It’s rich in taste and flavor too. Be informed that you can use it in many other meals that call for the use of the red sauce.

The sauce is free of cholesterol and it’s made using a blend of different spices with the richly grown tomatoes to make sauce. I can describe the sauce as a blend of rich texture, sweet aroma, hearty goodness, and rich flavors without additives and sugar.

3. Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese

Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese, 15 oz, 12 Pack

View on Amazon

This is made using the blend of vine-ripened tomatoes and cheese. The high-quality tomatoes are further enriched with real high-quality cheddar cheese.

What’s more, it contains no preservatives. For the chef who made the sauce, the addition of cheese is used to make it taste even better.

It will take your pizza to a different high level with the addition of extra virgin oil and other spices to make it. If you love healthy sauces then this is you’re on go-to sauce as it is created using organic tomatoes without the use of additives or preservatives.

It’s versatile for use since you can use it over your pasta or any size of pizza. It’s made with the thought of kids in mind by regulating the spiciness of the sauce. It also works for all the single people out there who don’t want to engage in intensive cooking.

Lastly, use it to enhance the taste of your meatballs when you have made meatballs.

4. Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef

Pastorelli® Pizza Sauce – Original Italian Pizza Sauce made with Imported Extra Virgin Pizza Olive Oil and Pecorino Romano Cheese Shredded – Since 1952 Family Pizza Sauce Recipe – 8 Ounce (Pack of 12)

View on Amazon

Now, this award-winning sauce is at a greater level than the normal. It has been in existence for more than 50 years. With this sauce, your friends will often wonder if you aren’t a true chef when you cook pizza. It has a smooth texture that will evenly spread on your pizza.

Made using unique herbs, it will make your pizza memorable for your guest. Most pizza sauces experience the problem of being either too spicy, sweet, or acidic. But that is not true for Pastorelli. It features a balance of flavors with a distance hint of spiciness.

It features tomato flavors which will compliment any pizza. Do you want a homemade pizza that compliments the restaurant ones? Use this sauce for entire goodness.

For all of those who are health conscious, this is just the sauce you need because it’s free of gluten, corn syrup and preservatives.

The best part is it contains a blend of cheese that creates the zesty flavor that will suit both the kid’s pizza and adult spiced pizza.

5. Eden Organic Pizza Pasta Sauce

Eden Organic Pizza Pasta Sauce, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 15-Ounce Cans (Pack of 12)

View on Amazon

Another thing and richly flavored sauce that’s made to best suit your pizza or pasta. It’s made using organic tomatoes and extra virgin olive oil.

For the garden flavor, the sauce is harvested and immediately cooked then packed. This ensures that they capture the nutrients and flavor.

The tomatoes are hand-cultivated and hand-harvested in Roma Italia. To enhance its flavor it uses sea salt, non-irradiated herbs, and spices. It’s free of gluten and is packed in a BPA-free lined can. It contains low fat and it’s an anti-oxidant that is further rich in vitamin A and K.

You can use the sauce on your pizza, pasta, baked burrito, tacos, enchiladas, and polenta. Some people use it in soups and stews making it a versatile sauce.

The homemade pizza sauce recipe

How Long Does Pasta Sauce Last?


image: Slice Pizzeria

Apparently, the pasta sauce may last up to a year after the set best by date. However, how long it takes, depends on several factors which include how it’s made and the set best by date. In most cases, the pasta sauce is made using tomatoes and sometimes cream or cheese.

The unopened can is the one that may last for up to a year and sometimes 6-12months. Note that, once you open the jar or can of sauce you should store it in the fridge. Since most pasta sauces don’t use preservatives, they will last anything from 5-10 days in the fridge.

The moment you open the sauce, cook with it in about 5 days but never more than 10 days. Before you use it, ensure that there are no mold formations.

Remember your safety against food poisoning is vital thus observe the following

Has your opened sauce developed molds? Consider discarding it.

The moment you open the jar, the sauce will begin changing from bright red to maroon color over time then it will further get thicker. After getting thicker the molds will begin to form. If by this time you haven’t used the whole jar then throw it away.

Best Pasta Sauce

6. Tomato Sauce by Uncle Steve’s

Tomato Sauce by Uncle Steve's - (2 Marinara 1 Arrabiata) for Spaghetti, Pasta or Pizza

View on Amazon

Do you remember the donkey sauce?

The man who made Donkey sauce has also made you a smoky, tasty, and flavorful sauce to use for your pasta. It features a crush of red peppers, crushed tomatoes, onions, carrots, basil, olive oil, sugar, parsley, and oregano.

The blended mixture of herbs and tomatoes are cooked together slowly to produce a sauce that is rich with flavors. It works well on your noodles and pasta mixing in perfectly and effortlessly. It will deliver the caramel sweetness and a depth of flavors.

Its hotness makes it easy to get through the winter season. This Italian sauce is worth every penny you put into it.

7. Rao’s Tomato Basil Sauce

Rao's Homemade Tomato Sauce, Tomato Basil, 24 oz, Versatile Pasta Sauce, Carb Conscious, Keto Friendly, All Natural, Premium Quality, Made with Slow-Simmered Italian Tomatoes & Basil

View on Amazon

This is a marina sauce that will work perfectly even for your pizza. Half of this jar will feed up to 4 people. This is a different variety of tomato sauce that has some basil thrown into it. This enhances the aroma and texture of the sauce.

It gives it a fresher taste with a balance of fruity olive oil, tomatoes, and basil. It’s an Italian flavor that features the use of naturally grown tomatoes. The tomatoes give the sauce a bright and fresh tomato flavor with balanced acidity.

The use of sugar further balances the salt making the sauce a balance of different flavors and textures.

8. RIGGO Pasta Spaghetti Sauce

RIGGO Pasta Spaghetti Sauce - 8 Keto Tomato Sauce Packets with Gourmet Italian Flavors (2 Servings Marinara Italiano)

View on Amazon

Are looking to make a delicious pasta that will blow you away?

The riggo pasta sauce is your go-to sauce. For most people, to enhance the flavor of the pasta, they add some meat to it. The riggo sauce is made with the meat in the sauce so you don’t need to spend more time cooking the meat.

The packaging of the sauce into 8 sachets where one sachet gives you two serving means you will only open the sachet you want to use and store the others for future servings. The sauce is easy to make as you don’t consume much time.

The seasoning is something that stands out.

Best Tomato Sauce Brands

9. Gourmet burgundy wine pasta sauce

Keto Burgundy Wine Pasta Sauce by Yo Mama's Foods - Pack of (2) - No Sugar Added, Low Carb, Low Sodium, Gluten Free, Paleo Friendly, and Made with Whole, Non-GMO Tomatoes

View on Amazon

This features a slowly simmered option of non-GMO tomatoes. I like the flavor and taste of the sauce which makes you feel satiated. It’s a blend of premium olive oil, burgundy wines then designed to emulate the authentic French cuisine. This makes it appear more natural and unparalleled in the market.

The delicious sauce is lean while pleasurable to eat yet healthy. It contains low amounts of sugar, carbohydrates, and sodium. It’s further made free from preservatives which makes it a super amazing sauce.

It uses vine-ripened tomatoes, fresh garlic, and onions, oregano, olive oils, basil, pepper, and sea salt. It’s further versatile for use as you can use it to cook pasta, cooked veggies, cooked chicken among other meals.

10. Pomi Tomato Sauce

Pomi Tomato Sauce, 17.64 Ounce (Pack of 12)

View on Amazon

Here is a taste of Italy.

The company brand name is popular for having high-quality sauces that are used in various meals. The tomatoes are organically produced at the local farms making them 100% natural. It contains no artificial ingredients.

The package features ingredients that are gluten-free and the production of the sauce is done in an environment that is gluten-free. The packaging is BPA-free making it a healthy quality as well. The package is home to garden-fresh flavors.

It’s convenient to use yet of premium quality.

Best Marina Sauce in A Jar

11. Trader Joe’s “Trader Giotto’s” Tomato Basil Marinara Sauce

Trader Joe's 'Trader Giotto's' Tomato Basil Marinara Sauce

View on Amazon

This is the epitome of easy sauces that you can use on all kinds of pasta or meals. If you wish to have a jar of blended whole tomatoes and tomato puree then this is your best choice. It features a flavorful sauce with balanced acidity.

It further has a humble array of herbs like garlic, oregano, and basil among others for the best flavor that will have you lick your fingers. Its consistency and texture are all you need for your pasta sauce.

Don’t only use it for pasta. Marina sauce fits your soups and stews, chicken or meats. To further enhance the flavor, you can add some parmesan, asiago, or Romano cheese. Use it as a flavor enhancer in most of your homemade sauces.

You don’t want to miss out on the blend of tastes with this sauce. Always have it in your pantry and if you wish you can enrich it by adding on pepper flakes, olives, anchovies, and mushrooms.

12. Ragu Old World Style Marinara

Ragu, Old World Style Marinara, 24 Ounce

View on Amazon

This is another marina sauce that features a savory blend of tomatoes, onions, and extra virgin oil giving it a classic flavor. It features the vine-ripened tomatoes that are meant to flavor the whole family meals. It has tomato crunches, tomato puree, calcium chloride, and soybean oil.

It further uses spices that will make it retain its natural authentic flavor. Ragu marina is a sauce that uses tomatoes grown in California. It has no additives and is rich in vitamins A and C.

13. Cucina Antica Garlic Marinara

Cucina Antica - Garlic Marinara Pasta Sauce - 25oz (Pack of 6) - Non GMO, Whole 30 Approved, Gluten Free

View on Amazon

The cucina features an all-natural ingredient without added sugar. It’s made using plum tomatoes together with the real extra virgin oil. This is my favorite pasta sauce.

Its additional garlic and basil are used to flavor the sauce further while helping in cutting the calories. Although it appears sweet the tomatoes are the reason for the sweetness.

They only use non-GMO products and make them in a gluten-free environment without gluten. Tossing a little of the cucina sauce into your pasta makes it yum yum.

The Healthy Pizza Sauce

14. Traditional Pizza Sauce 14 Oz-classico

Traditional Pizza Sauce 14 Oz-classico [Pack of 3]

View on Amazon

Looking back to the traditional pizza, it was made using flatbread with toppings which included tomatoes, basil, garlic, and olive oil. Today, the combination of these ingredients with oregano and fennel forms the famous Classico sauce.

This is the signature of the classic company. It’s a healthy product because it’s made using healthy natural ingredients and it contains no traces of gluten. I’ve used this one and I find it healthier than most other sauces. It further contains no preservatives.

The Best Spaghetti Sauce

15. Chef Boyardee Spaghetti Sauce With Meat

No products found.

No products found.

The spaghetti sauce is mostly the same as the ones used over different kinds of pasta. However, you can also choose this one that is specifically meant for spaghetti. For your wholesome and nutritious sauce, buy the Chef Boyardee.

It features the use of tomatoes that were left to ripen under the sun, the Italian seasoning, spices, and other authentic ingredients.

How to Make A Pasta Sauce Better Tasting

You can enhance the flavor of your sauce by using a few ingredients here and there. But you must follow the tips below.

  • Heating

You might think that you can just pour the sauce over your cooked pasta as you do with other condiments but this won’t work. Always heat it before pouring it over your cooked pasta. The heating warms up the spices and flavors making it easy to begin releasing the desirable aromas.

  • Just season it and cook it as below


  • Onions
  • Olive oil
  • Sliced mushroom
  • The sauce
  • Italian seasoning
  • Some oregano, salt, and pepper
  • Butter


In your saucepan, begin by melting the butter as you heat the olive oil.

Go ahead and add your garlic, mushrooms and chopped onions then cook until they are soft.

Add the spaghetti sauce as well as all other seasonings and stir well

Simmer it over low heat for about 10 minutes as you keep seasoning to ensure it doesn’t get scorched.

Serve hot over your cooked pasta.

  • You can enrich it

Some people may want it enriched. With the use of butter or cream, you can enrich the sauce. you may also use meat to enrich it even more. The meats could be bacon or ground beef. This will create umami flavors.

  • Bake it if necessary

You can bake your jarred sauces so that the sugars can caramelize better. This is only to enhance the flavors.

Things to Look for In Your Canned Pizza Sauce

  • Additional sugar

One common thing with processed or canned food is that they mostly contain a large amount of sugar. This may at times influence the tastes of the sauce to the negative. Of course, if you need sugary foods you should buy sweets and pastries.

However, a can of tomato sauce that is too sugary will influence the meal in a way you may not like. If you are also watching what you eat then the sugary sauce isn’t the best. Go and check the nutrients and ingredients information before buying the sauce.

  • Other veggies

For those who don’t enjoy eating veggies, this may help. There are a vast number of sauces that have vegetables blended in. Of course, the veggies may not work effectively because they are processed but it will help in a way.

  • Which pizza are you cooking?

Different sauces will suit different crusts of pizza. You most probably know there is a thin crust and thick one. When you are buying a sauce for the thick crust you should know that it might not work on your thin-crusted options.

For example, the thin crust pizza shouldn’t use a watery sauce as it will make it soggy and unfoldable.

  • The flavors

I know most people love the spicy flavor. But what if you have kids in the house? They enjoy a sweet and mild flavor as opposed to hot, garlic, and herbs flavor. In short, make sure you go for the best flavors that suit your palate needs.

Otherwise, you may buy the sauce and throw it without using it.

  • Which texture appeals more?

The sauce world is home to varying textures. Whether you like it smooth or chunky you will get one that suits you. If you enjoy crunchy vegetables and tomatoes good for you but it never works for me. I prefer the smooth sauce.

  • Which is best the jar or canned sauce?

When it’s the tomato sauce I choose the jar storage because that assures me of the absence of BPA toxins that would otherwise leach into the sauce.

How to Find the Tasty Sauces Out of The Many in The Store

Finding the best tasting sauce might be tricky but you should pay keen attention to how it’s ripened to how it is packaged to be sure you bring home the perfect sauce.

  • It should contain basil

For any tomato sauce, the number one ingredient is normal tomatoes. The basil then comes in a close second. You can literary make this sauce at home when you have the ripe tomatoes and fresh basil along with seasonings. Thus, ensure your sauce has fresh basil.

  • Do not ignore the amount of sugar

We have mentioned this in the previous subtopic and this is just to emphasize it. You don’t want to find yourself eating sugar in the name of a sauce. You only need TO take a few grams of sugar for each bottle.

  • What are the ingredients?

A healthy, flavorful, and delicious pizza is determined by the ingredients you use to make it. Go for a sauce with garlic, basil, spices and seasonings, olive oil, and any other high-quality ingredients. If you will buy a high-quality sauce, you will have your pizza tasting like the chef created one at home.

  • The price

Some people think that if a sauce is highly prized then it must be tastier. This is never the case because the cost is just about the brand. You may have a cheap sauce that tastes good.

Where to Buy Tomato Sauce

When you want to buy different pizza and pasta sauces, you should go online to find a variance of choices. Also, go to the large supermarkets and grocery stores for different brands.

Pasta Sauce Vs Pizza Sauce

While writing this article, one question kept hoping on my mind. Is there a difference between pasta sauce and pizza sauce?

And yes, there is a slight difference. You may decide to use pasta sauce over pizza but, the problem is that it might not come out as good.

Let’s see the difference

Texture: the pasta sauce is generally smoother yet thinner than the counterpart pizza sauce. Although the pizza sauce is thicker it normally has some pulp and texture.

Water content: the pasta sauce contains more water than the pulp.

The flavorings: pizza sauce gets much of its flavor from the tomatoes. On the other hand, the marina has more onions and garlic to enhance the flavors. It also contains more herbs than the pizza sauce.

Fat content: pizza sauce must contain a bit of fat from olive oil that is blended in while pasta sauce has minimal fat.

The cooking: you don’t need to cook pizza sauce. It’s just a blend of tomato sauce and other herbs while pasta sauce is cooked by simmering.

Leave a Comment