Looking for a quick and easy way to have a hearty meal but don’t feel like cooking?
We all have those moments where you just want to sit back and relax after a long day at work.
Coming home to ready-cooked food after a long day is a dream, and cooking is the last thing on our minds.
All you need to do is order food online if you want this dream to come true.
One of the most popular foods for a fast meal is pizza. Pizzas are a go-to comfort food to feed a crowd at affordable prices.
If you want delicious and affordable pizza, Papa John’s reigns among the top pizza places in the United States.
No matter what your taste, there is a flavor for everyone in the family or in the group.
Papa John’s offers a variety of toppings, sauces, and crusts for you to choose from.
You can choose from among their specialty pizzas or create your own masterpiece from scratch.
The pizzas at Papa John’s come in seven categories: Create Your Own Pizza, Papa Picks, Crispy Parm Crust, Handcrafted Specialties, Handcrafted Meatless Specialties, Gluten Free Crust with Ancient Grains, and Local Flavors.
Though Papa John’s menu has a lot to offer, a few ultimately stand out and remain a crowd favorite.
In this guide, I have chosen the top 10 most popular pizzas at Papa John’s.
In no particular order, the top 10 Best Papa John’s pizzas are:
- Pepperoni Pizza
- Garden Fresh Pizza
- Sausage Pizza
- Cheese Pizza
- Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza
- Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
- Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
- The Works Pizza
- Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
- Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
Contents
- 1 1. Pepperoni Pizza
- 2 2. Garden Fresh Pizza
- 3 3. Sausage Pizza
- 4 4. Cheese Pizza
- 5 5. Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza
- 6 6. Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
- 7 7. Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
- 8 8. The Works Pizza
- 9 9. Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
- 10 10. Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
- 11 Which Papa John ‘s Pizza Is Your Top Pick?
1. Pepperoni Pizza
View this post on Instagram
Pepperoni Pizza is uncomplicated and just the way you expect a pepperoni pizza to be – smoky and soft pepperoni flavors.
Experience the perfection of cheese pulling and melting with this pizza style.
A classic pizza, like Pepperoni Pizza, never goes out of style. Nothing beats the timeless flavors of pepperoni drizzled in Papa John’s signature pizza sauce.
It is baked with real mozzarella cheese, a perfect combination in every bite.
For as low as $8.99, you can get a small Pepperoni Pizza with the original crust.
It is also available for thin crust, epic stuffed crust, and NY style.
If you want a burst of pepperoni, you can also order it with Papa John’s epic pepperoni stuffed crust.
| Papa Picks – Pepperoni Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 210 | $8.99 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 230 | $11.09 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 320 | $14.09 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 330 | $17.09 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 250 | $14.09 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 390 | $17.09 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 380 | $18.09 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 360 | $17.09 |
2. Garden Fresh Pizza
View this post on Instagram
Pizza without meat can be delicious and flavorful thanks to Garden Fresh Pizza. It is a lighter and healthier option than meat-filled pizzas.
Garden Fresh Pizza has all the delicious vegetables in one slice. It is the perfect pizza for those looking for meatless options with low calories per slice.
Green peppers, ripe black olives, Crimini mushrooms, and vine-ripened Roma tomatoes add flavor to this dish.
If you want the lowest calorie per slice, go for Garden Fresh Pizza cooked with a gluten-free crust.
Garden Fresh Pizza on the gluten-free crust is only 140 calories per slice for $14.99.
The cheapest option is with the original crust in a small pizza size for $12.49.
The original crust option is the next best option for the lowest calories, for only 190 calories per slice.
| Handcrafted Meatless Specialties – Garden Fresh Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 190 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 200 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 280 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 300 | $20.99 |
| Crispy Parm Crust | 8 Slices | 350 | $19.29 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 210 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 340 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 340 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 310 | $20.99 |
| Gluten Free | 6 Slices | 140 | $14.99 |
3. Sausage Pizza
If you are looking for an alternative to pepperoni, Sausage Pizza is definitely the next best thing.
Get the meaty flavors you desire while experimenting with sauce options for an irresistible taste.
Sausage Pizza is one of the top Papa Picks loaded with savory sausage and real mozzarella cheese.
It is a classic pizza featuring Papa John’s signature pizza sauce. You can get it in all crust styles except gluten free crust.
Prices start at $8.99 for an original crust small-size pizza. This type of pizza comes in six slices at 220 calories per slice.
Try it with an epic pepperoni stuffed crust to get the best of both worlds of pepperoni and sausage.
| Papa Picks – Sausage Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 220 | $8.99 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 240 | $11.09 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 330 | $14.09 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 340 | $17.09 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 260 | $14.09 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 400 | $17.09 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 390 | $18.09 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 370 | $17.09 |
4. Cheese Pizza
Cheese with garlic parmesan crust pizza
Cheese Pizza is one of the most fuss-free pizzas there is. It is simple yet the most satisfying pizza for vegetarians and fans of cheese.
Choose this pizza specialty as your foundation when creating your custom pizza from start to finish.
Cheese Pizza features Papa John’s signature pizza sauce topped with a generous amount of real mozzarella cheese.
It is baked to a golden brown color with cheese that melts in your mouth.
You can have the lowest calorie per slice with an original crust for a small size of 180 calories per slice.
The lowest price costs $8.99 for six slices.
| Papa Picks – Cheese Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 180 | $8.99 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 190 | $11.09 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 270 | $14.09 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 280 | $17.09 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 200 | $14.09 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 360 | $17.09 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 330 | $18.09 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 310 | $17.09 |
5. Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage & six cheesse pizza
Want a mix of sausage, pepperoni, and cheese? The Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza at Papa John’s is an excellent choice for cheese lovers who want a combination of savory meats.
It is definitely the best bet for those looking for something heavy and meaty to satiate all cravings.
In one slice of pizza, you get perfectly blended six kinds of cheese: Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, Fontina, Provolone and Mozzarella.
The taste is completed with loads of pepperoni and sausage, topped with Italian herb seasonings.
It is worth mentioning that the Italian herb seasoning contains gluten, which is not ideal for those avoiding gluten completely.
Prices start at $12.49 for an original crust small-size pizza and can go high as $22.29 for an epic stuffed crust large pizza.
| Handcrafted Specialties – Pepperoni, Sausage & Six Cheese Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 260 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 280 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 390 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 410 | $20.99 |
| Crispy Parm Crust | 8 Slices | 460 | $19.29 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 320 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 450 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 450 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 480 | $20.99 |
6. Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
Hawaiian BBQ chicken pizza
Pineapple on pizza has been the debate for decades.
Whether you are pro or anti-pineapple on pizzas, you can be guaranteed you won’t be disappointed with Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza.
Be in the tropics with Papa John’s Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza, offering a tropical twist of local favorites.
Each slice comes with its popular smoky BBQ sauce base. It is covered with grilled chicken, juicy bacon, fresh onions, and real mozzarella cheese.
On top of that, you get the sweet and tangy flavors of pineapple tidbits, completing the aloha vibes you are looking for.
An original crust Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza costs $12.49 for small, $15.49 for medium, $18.29 for large, and $20.99 for extra large. The calories per slice are between 230 and 430 calories per slice.
| Local Flavors – Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 230 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 250 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 360 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 370 | $20.99 |
| Crispy Parm Crust | 8 Slices | 420 | $19.29 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 280 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 420 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 420 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 430 | $20.99 |
| Gluten Free | 6 Slices | – | $14.99 |
7. Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
Extra cheesy alfredo pizza
Another meatless option favorite, the Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza is ideal for vegetarians, cheese lovers, or those looking to cut off or cut down on meat.
It is low on calories, starting at 210 calories per slice for an original crust small-size pizza. This pizza boasts its rich and creamy Alfredo sauce base.
Along with its white sauce base, it is loaded with more cheese than usual.
As a result, you can expect a creamy and cheesy mouthfeel. It is smothered in a blend of cheeses, including provolone, Asiago, Fontina, and real mozzarella.
You can choose your choice of crust style, including original, crispy parm, thin crust, epic stuffed crust, epic pepperoni stuffed crust, NY style, and gluten free.
It costs about $12.49 for a small original crust pizza and up to $22.29 for an epic pepperoni stuffed crust large pizza.
| Handcrafted Meatless Specialties – Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 210 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 230 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 320 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 330 | $20.99 |
| Crispy Parm Crust | 8 Slices | 390 | $19.29 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 250 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 380 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 380 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 370 | $20.99 |
| Gluten Free | 6 Slices | 180 | $14.99 |
8. The Works Pizza
The Works Pizza has all your desired ingredients with a kick. Indulge in your favorite savory meats, including pepperoni, Italian sausage, and julienne-cut Canadian bacon.
It is combined with vegetables, from fresh onions to green peppers and Crimini mushrooms.
For finishing touches, the pizza is completed with ripe black olives, Papa John’s signature pizza sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
The Works Pizza is also best enjoyed with your favorite dipping sauce, such as barbeque, ranch, special garlic, or cheese.
Get the lowest calorie intake with only 230 calories per slice for the original crust in small and medium.
If you don’t mind the calories, best to go with epic stuffed crust or epic pepperoni stuffed crust in large size for 400 calories per slice.
| Handcrafted Specialties – The Works Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 230 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 230 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 340 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 360 | $20.99 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 270 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 400 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 400 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 390 | $20.99 |
9. Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
Papa John’s Fresh Spinach and Tomato Alfredo pizza pairs fresh vegetables with creamy Alfredo sauce for a delicious meal.
Its signature Alfredo sauce is blended with a combination of Parmesan and Romano cheeses.
It is loaded with fresh baby spinach, Roma tomatoes, and real mozzarella cheese.
All in all, it is a perfect treat for every vegetable lover.
Lastly, a classic Italian seasoning is added as a final touch. This pizza offers one of the lowest calorie counts, with only 190 calories per slice for an original crust small-size pizza.
Go for crispy parm crust, epic stuffed crust large, and epic pepperoni stuffed crust large for more calories of up to 350 per slice.
| Handcrafted Meatless Specialties – Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 190 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 200 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 280 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 300 | $20.99 |
| Crispy Parm Crust | 8 Slices | 350 | $19.29 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 210 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 350 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 350 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 310 | $20.99 |
10. Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
Can’t get enough of cheese? Papa John’s Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza is worth a try, made with six kinds of cheese: mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, provolone, and fontina.
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza is freshly baked and seasoned with Italian herbs. It is a blend of six cheeses topped with Papa John’s signature pizza sauce.
With its layer of tomato goodness from its red signature pizza sauce, it makes it an excellent alternative to the Alfredo white sauce.
It is recommended especially if you are not a fan of white sauces. However, if you are lactose-intolerant, you might want to steer away from cheese overload.
Get this pizza for all crust styles and sizes except gluten free crust. Prices start at $12.49 and up to $22.29.
| Handcrafted Meatless Specialties – Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | |||
| Crust and Size | Slices | Calories per Slice | Price |
| Original Crust Small | 6 Slices | 220 | $12.49 |
| Original Crust Medium | 8 Slices | 230 | $15.49 |
| Original Crust Large | 8 Slices | 320 | $18.29 |
| Original Crust Extra Large | 10 Slices | 330 | $20.99 |
| Crispy Parm Crust | 8 Slices | 390 | $19.29 |
| Thin Crust Large | 8 Slices | 250 | $18.29 |
| Epic Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 380 | $21.29 |
| Epic Pepperoni Stuffed Crust Large | 8 Slices | 380 | $22.29 |
| NY Style Extra Large | 8 slices | 360 | $20.99 |
Which Papa John ‘s Pizza Is Your Top Pick?
Meaty, veggie goodness, and cheesy – whichever flavor you are going for, Papa John’s surely delivers the best taste and style.
Try the classic Pepperoni Pizza, the famous The Works Pizza, or the crowd-favorite Cheese Pizza.
Maybe you’ll discover your favorites by trying all specialties and classics.
Nevertheless, there is always an option to create your own pizza and choose your own custom options.
Build your perfect pizza with a bit of tweaking of your favorite toppings and sides.
Do you already have a favorite Papa John’s Pizza? Let us know in the comments section below.
Share your favorites and recommendations with fellow pizza lovers.
Keep up with the latest pizza reviews, recommendations, and comparisons by following us on Pinterest, Facebook, and Instagram.
