Pizzas have been a staple for decades and are one of the top choices for comfort foods.
It is the ideal meal or snack for every type of gathering, whether you are having a family pizza night, a girl’s/guy’s chill weekend, or a movie marathon.
Now and then, pizzerias would come up with new and unique pizza flavors for every season to create new experiences.
But a few popular pizza styles have always remained on the menu, such as pepperoni, cheese, Hawaiian, all-meat, all-veggie, and supreme.
In this article, we explore more about Supreme Pizza and its toppings.
It is unclear how Supreme Pizzas started and who created it.
Nevertheless, it has become a beloved pizza style with many variations created in the United States and throughout the world.
Although Supreme Pizza comes in various versions, there are some common toppings you will always find.
This article explores the most common Supreme Pizza toppings used, from meats to veggies and cheese.
As a bonus, this article also shares where to order Supreme Pizzas in the United States.
And if you want to create your own, it is possible as well with several pizza places allowing custom pizzas or simply making one yourself at home.
Whether you are a Supreme Pizza lover already or will try it for the first time, this article is a good read to discover more about Supreme Pizza.
In summary, here’s what you will read about:
The Most Popular Supreme Pizza Toppings
- Meat Toppings
- Veggie Toppings
- Mozzarella Cheese
- Tomato-Based Sauce
Famous Pizzerias With Supreme Pizza Toppings
- Pizza Hut
- Domino’s
- Papa John’s
- Godfather’s
- Marco’s
- Jet’s Pizza
- Little Caesars
- Costco
Contents
- 1 The Most Popular Supreme Pizza Toppings
- 2 Famous Pizzerias With Supreme Pizza Toppings
- 2.1 Pizza Hut’s Supreme Pizza
- 2.2 Domino’s ExtravaganZZa and Deluxe Pizzas
- 2.3 Papa John’s The Works Pizza
- 2.4 Godfather’s Classic Combo and Humble Pie
- 2.5 Marco’s Deluxe Pizza
- 2.6 Jet’s Pizza Eugene Supreme and Super Special
- 2.7 Little Caesars Ultimate Supreme
- 2.8 Cotsco’s Frozen Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza
- 3 Top Your Pizza With The Splendor Of Supreme Toppings
The Most Popular Supreme Pizza Toppings
Meat Toppings
Pepperoni
Pepperoni is a staple topping not only used for supreme pizzas but for other flavors as well.
It is salty and savory that goes with any meat and veggie toppings.
Moreover, it adds a touch of spiciness to the overall taste.
Pepperoni can be either cured pork or beef, but it can also be a mix of both.
However, some pepperonis can be made from turkey and chicken.
Italian Sausage
View this post on Instagram
Adding to the meaty flavors is a traditional Italian sausage.
It is typically made from ground pork with a milder punch than pepperoni.
Its juicy and tender texture pairs well with other meat toppings.
Aside from Italian sausage, mild fennel sausage or sweet breakfast-style sausage are also great alternatives.
Ham
Although it is not the most common supreme topping, you can find ham in many Supreme Pizza versions.
It is another excellent addition to the combination of salty meats, bringing more distinct textures to every bite.
Ham is a popular meat topping for pizza and is often paired with other ingredients like mushrooms, peppers, and onions.
These toppings are commonly found on Supreme Pizzas, which are known for their diverse and flavorful combination of ingredients.
Bacon
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, and ham are probably the most common Supreme Pizza topping.
However, you may encounter some pizzerias adding bacon to the mix.
Bacon is another frequently chosen meat topping for pizza. Its smoky flavor makes it better, especially when it is extra crispy.
If you like bacon on Supreme Pizzas, you can go for Papa John’s The Works Pizza.
Beef
View this post on Instagram
Ground beef can also be used as a topping for Supreme Pizzas.
In fact, Pizza Hut’s Supreme Pizza is actually made from seasoned pork and beef.
You can also find beef ingredients in Godfather’s Classic Combo and Domino’s ExtravaganZZa.
Beef is not only one of the most popular pizza toppings for meat, but it is also highly versatile and pairs well with vegetables and cheeses
Veggie Toppings
Green Bell Peppers
View this post on Instagram
You can never have Supreme Pizza without green bell peppers.
It has a robust flavor that compliments well with other ingredients.
Get tender slices of these slightly sweet peppers to contrast the salty meats and add more nutritional elements to the pizza.
However, you may encounter some pizzerias omitting this ingredient and still have a great tasting Supreme Pizza.
Black Olives
View this post on Instagram
Another mainstay ingredient is diced black olives, but green olives can also be a good alternative.
It adds a touch of salty, briny, and floral flavors.
Black olives balance with the cheese and tomato sauce harmoniously.
Mushrooms
For more nutritional value to a Supreme Pizza, mushrooms are also commonly added and are a perfect fit.
The added mushrooms give the pizza an earthy, umami, and slightly meaty flavor.
Plus, it adds a soft and chewy texture to the mouthfeel.
Onions
View this post on Instagram
Last but not least, onion is another typical vegetable adding a bit of sweetness and crunch to a slice.
It becomes caramelized when cooked and adds a pungent flavor as well.
Onion is the most versatile ingredient that goes with any pizza style and is also appealing for its nutritional value.
Mozzarella Cheese
View this post on Instagram
Supreme Pizza typically uses mozzarella cheese.
Some pizza places may also add other types of cheese such as cheddar or romano.
Cheese is an important ingredient that completes the taste and texture of any pizza.
It also plays a crucial role in holding all the toppings together.
Not only does cheese balance out the flavors of the toppings and tomato sauce, but it also adds that melty and stretchy consistency you want in a pizza.
Tomato-Based Sauce
View this post on Instagram
Not exactly a topping, but the sauce serves as the foundation of a pizza.
Supreme Pizzas commonly use a classic tomato sauce base that is tangy with a touch of sweetness.
It gives the pizza its slightly acidic flavor, perfectly balancing salty and sweet toppings and creamy cheese.
Famous Pizzerias With Supreme Pizza Toppings
Hungry for Supreme Pizza?
Order one from famous pizzerias in the United States.
You can usually find Supreme Pizzas on the menu using the same label, ‘Supreme’.
If you can’t seem to find Supreme Pizza on the menu, the pizzeria may have used a different name instead.
In this case, try looking at the pizza’s ingredients and check if the pizza uses the typical Supreme Pizza toppings mentioned above.
If yes, then that pizza is most likely the Supreme Pizza version of that pizzeria.
I have curated a list of pizzerias where you can order a Supreme Pizza.
Check out the list below!
Pizza Hut’s Supreme Pizza
Get the perfect balance of sweet and salty toppings with Pizza Hut’s Supreme Pizza.
You can find mushrooms, green bell peppers, onions, and three kinds of meat: pepperoni, seasoned pork, and beef.
Try it on five Pizza Hut crusts for a different experience every time you order.
Supreme Pizza pairs well with the traditional Hand Tossed crust or a crunchy Thin’ N Crispy Crust®.
Prices start at $14.89 for medium size, $16.89 for large size, $4.99 for personal size, and $12.99 for the small size of gluten-free crust.
Domino’s ExtravaganZZa and Deluxe Pizzas
View this post on Instagram
Domino’s is an example of a pizzeria without a pizza labeled ‘Supreme’.
However, if you check the pizza’s ingredients, Domino’s ExtravaganZZa and Deluxe pizzas are not only the best pizzas at Domino’s, but they are also two types of Supreme Pizzas.
Domino’s ExtravaganZZa is among its best-selling pizzas, loved for its overload of Supreme Pizza toppings.
It has a combination of four types of meat: pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, and beef.
Then, you get a mix of delicious non-meat toppings, including onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.
On the other hand, Domino’s Deluxe pizza is its simpler version of supreme.
It has the basic Supreme Pizza toppings, including pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, and onions.
Order Domino’s ExtravaganZZa and Deluxe pizzas in five different crust styles: Hand Tossed, Gluten Free, Crunchy Thin Crust, Handmade Pan, and Brooklyn Style.
You can get the cheapest pizza for $12.99 for a small Hand Tossed pizza or the largest size for $20.99 for a Brooklyn Style crust.
Papa John’s The Works Pizza
If you want smoky bacon added to your Supreme Pizza, go for Papa John’s The Works Pizza.
This pizza has a bit of everything, including pepperoni, spicy Italian sausage, and julienne-cut Canadian bacon.
Balancing the flavors are fresh-cut onions, green peppers, mushrooms, ripe black olives, and creamy mozzarella cheese.
You can get it in all Papa John’s crust styles: Original Crust, Gluten-Free, Crispy Parm Crust, Epic Stuffed Crust, Epic Pepperoni-Stuffed Crust, NY Style Crust, and Thin Crust.
The lowest price is for a small-sized Original crust at $12.49.
If you want the largest pizza for a group, opt for the extra large with an Original or NY Style crust for $20.99.
Godfather’s Classic Combo and Humble Pie
Godfather’s has two pizzas closest to being called a Supreme Pizza.
You can either order Godfather’s Classic Combo or Humble Pie for $20.49 for a large Golden crust pizza.
The Classic Combo is packed with pepperoni, seasoned beef, sausage, diced onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
This pizza combo has all the typical Supreme Pizza topping you need except for the green peppers.
On the other hand, the Humble Pie is topped with fewer ingredients, including pepperoni, Italian sausage, diced onions, and crisp green peppers.
What’s missing in this pizza combo are black olives and mushrooms, which are both found in Classic Combo.
Both pizza styles are available in two sizes: mini and large.
Godfather’s offers only two types of crust, Golden and Thin crust styles.
A mini-sized pizza costs $6.99 and is only available for the golden crust.
Marco’s Deluxe Pizza
Marco’s Deluxe Pizza is an excellent option that has all the essential toppings except black olives.
It includes pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions.
However, you can always customize this pizza and add black olives from the topping options to complete the Supreme Pizza ingredients.
As a finisher, this pizza is combined with Marco’s signature sauce and three-cheese blend.
Get Marco’s Deluxe Pizza in all crust styles: Original Crust, Thick, Lite, Thin, and Cauliflower.
Original Crust is available in all sizes, including small, medium, large, and XL, whereas Thick and Thin crusts are available in all sizes except XL.
If you are going for Cauliflower crust, you can only order it in small sizes.
Jet’s Pizza Eugene Supreme and Super Special
Jet’s Pizza offers two pizzas similar to Supreme Pizza.
Order their Eugene Supreme or Super Special in small, large, 8 Corner Pizza, extra large, or party tray sizes.
Eugene Supreme uses one type of meat, Italian sausage, paired with onions, green peppers, and mild peppers.
For Super Special, it is filled with pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
Super Special is the closest to having all the ingredients of a Supreme Pizza without black olives.
However, you can still add toppings to complete your Supreme Pizza.
You can add extra toppings like pepperoni (10-40 cal.), bacon (20-80 cal.), or black olives (10-30 cal.) if you desire.
Prices start at $18.15 for a small 4 Corner Pizza, Thin Crust, or Hand-Tossed Round crust style.
Little Caesars Ultimate Supreme
Get an Ultimate Supreme at Little Caesars for $10.00 in a large size.
It comes with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
One pizza has eight slices, with about 313 calories per slice or a total of 2,510 calories per whole pizza.
This pizza is not customizable, so you cannot add extra toppings if you want.
However, Little Caesars has a Create Your Own feature where you can make your own Supreme Pizza by choosing your crust and supreme toppings.
Cotsco’s Frozen Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Costco is not a pizzeria but a great place to buy frozen Supreme Pizzas.
It is good to know there is an option to stock up your freezer with Supreme Pizzas at home and cook it anytime you want.
Go for Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza for $14.69, which comes in two packs.
This pizza has a combination of veggie and meat toppings, including pepperoni, savory sausage, red bell peppers, yellow bell peppers, green bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, and zucchini.
It is one of the best frozen pizza options in Costco. It uses a gluten-free cauliflower crust and tomato-based sauce.
The final touch – you get a blend of three types of cheese: mozzarella, parmesan, and romano.
For a golden brown crust, bake this frozen pizza for 17 to 19 minutes.
Table of Comparison of Supreme Pizzas in the United States
| Pizzeria | Pizza | Crust | Personal | Small | Medium | Large | X-Large |
| Pizza Hut | Supreme Pizza
(Pepperoni, seasoned pork, beef, mushrooms, green bell peppers, and onions)
|
Hand Tossed | Not Available | Not Available | $14.89
240 cal/slice |
$16.89
330 cal/slice |
Not Available |
| Thin’ N Crispy Crust® | Not Available | Not Available | $14.89
210 cal/slice |
$16.89
290 cal/slice |
Not Available | ||
| Original Pan® Crust | $4.99
170 cal/slice |
Not Available | $15.89
280 cal/slice |
$17.89
410 cal/slice |
Not Available | ||
| Original Stuffed Crust® | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $18.79
360 cal/slice |
Not Available | ||
| Gluten Free | Not Available | $12.99
130 cal/slice |
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Domino‘s | ExtravaganZZa
(Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, beef, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, and mozzarella)
|
Hand Tossed
|
Not Available | $12.99
270 Calories / 1 slice (1/6 of pizza) |
$15.99
280 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
$18.99
390 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
Not Available |
| Gluten Free | Not Available | $15.99
450 Calories / 2 slices (1/3 of pizza) |
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Crunchy Thin Crust | Not Available | Not Available | $15.99
460 Calories / 1/4 of pizza |
$18.99
310 Calories / 1/8 of pizza |
Not Available | ||
| Handmade Pan | Not Available | Not Available | $17.99
390 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Brooklyn Style | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $18.99
400 Calories / 1 slice (1/6 of pizza) |
$20.99
530 Calories / 1 slice (1/6 of pizza) |
||
| Deluxe Pizza
(Pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and mozzarella)
|
Hand Tossed
|
Not Available | $12.99
220 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
$15.99
220 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
$18.99
310 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
Not Available | |
| Gluten Free | Not Available | $15.99
350 Calories / 2 slices (1/3 of pizza) |
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Crunchy Thin Crust | Not Available | Not Available | $15.99
350 Calories / 1/4 of pizza |
$18.99
230 Calories / 1/8 of pizza |
Not Available | ||
| Handmade Pan | Not Available | Not Available | $17.99
340 Calories / 1 slice (1/8 of pizza) |
Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Brooklyn Style | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $18.99
300 Calories / 1 slice (1/6 of pizza) |
$20.99
390 Calories / 1 slice (1/6 of pizza) |
||
| Papa John‘s | The Works Pizza
(Pepperoni, julienne-cut Canadian bacon, spicy Italian sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives) |
Original Crust | Not Available | $12.49 230 cal /slice, 6 slices | $15.49 230 cal /slice, 8 slices | $18.29 340 cal /slice, 8 slices | $20.99 360 cal /slice, 10 slices |
| Gluten-Free | Not Available | $14.99 170 cal /slice, 6 slices | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Crispy Parm Crust | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $19.29 410 cal /slice, 8 slices | Not Available | ||
| Epic Stuffed Crust | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $21.29 400 cal /slice, 8 slices | Not Available | ||
| Epic Pepperoni-Stuffed Crust | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $22.29 400 cal /slice, 8 slices | Not Available | ||
| NY Style Crust | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $20.99 390 cal /slice, 8 slices | ||
| Thin Crust | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $18.29 270 cal /slice, 8 slices | Not Available | ||
| Godfather‘s | Classic Combo
(Pepperoni, seasoned beef, sausage, diced onions, black olives, and mushrooms) |
Golden | $6.99
Mini size 200 Cal/ slice (4 Slices) |
Not Available | Not Available | $20.49
260 to 310 Cal/ slice (10 Slices) |
Not Available |
| Thin | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $20.49
260 to 310 Cal/ slice (10 Slices) |
Not Available | ||
| Humble Pie
(Pepperoni, Italian sausage, diced onions, green peppers) |
Golden | $6.99
Mini size 220 Cal/ slice (4 Slices) |
Not Available | Not Available | $20.49
280 to 330 Cal/ slice (10 Slices) |
Not Available | |
| Thin | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | $20.49
280 to 330 Cal/ slice (10 Slices) |
Not Available | ||
| Marco‘s | Deluxe Pizza
(Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and signature sauce and three-cheese blend) |
Original Crust | Not Available | $12.99
290 cal. per slice |
$15.99
300 cal. per slice |
$17.99
400 cal. per slice |
$20.99
350 cal. per slice |
| Thick | Not Available | $12.99
330 cal. per slice |
$15.99
340 cal. per slice |
$17.99
460 cal. per slice |
Not Available | ||
| Lite | Not Available | Not Available | $15.99
270 cal. per slice |
$17.99
360 cal. per slice |
$20.99
310 cal. per slice |
||
| Thin | Not Available | $12.99
250 cal. per slice |
$15.99
260 cal. per slice |
$17.99
340 cal. per slice |
Not Available | ||
| Cauliflower | Not Available | $15.99
290 cal. per slice |
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Jet‘s Pizza | Eugene Supreme®
(Italian sausage, onions, green peppers, and mild peppers) 270 – 420 cal/slice
Super Special (Pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers) 240 – 400 cal/slice |
Crust | Small | Large | 8 Corner Pizza | Extra Large | Party Tray |
| 4 Corner Pizza | $18.15
|
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Thin Crust | $18.15
|
$24.03
|
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Hand-Tossed Round | $18.15
|
$24.03 | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Gluten-Free | $19.00
|
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Cauliflower Crust
|
$19.00
|
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Detroit-Style Deep Dish | Not Available | $24.03
|
$30.02
|
$34.52
|
$64.16
|
||
| NY-Style Round | Not Available | $24.03
|
Not Available | Not Available | Not Available | ||
| Little Caesars | Ultimate Supreme
(Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers) |
Large Round Pizzas | $10.00 | ||||
| Costco | Frozen Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza
(Pepperoni, savory sausage, red bell peppers, yellow bell peppers, green bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, and zucchini) |
Cauliflower Crust | $14.69 for two packs | ||||
Top Your Pizza With The Splendor Of Supreme Toppings
Supreme Pizza toppings offer endless combinations that can suit any preference.
You can get it at any popular pizzeria in the United States.
However, not all pizzerias follow the same toppings and have their own unique take on Supreme Pizzas.
Nevertheless, all is good as long as you get the typical supreme toppings, including pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, bacon, beef, green bell peppers, black olives, mushrooms, and onion.
Take note that the prices and pizza styles listed in the table of comparison above may vary per store location.
Check with your preferred pizzeria’s store location for the latest offers and prices.
Get your hands on different versions of Supreme Pizzas, or maybe make your own with the pizzeria’s Create Your Own or Build Your Pizza feature.
If you want to make it at home, there are plenty of Supreme Pizza recipes on the internet.
Just make sure you have all the ingredients ready, including pizza dough, pizza sauce, meat toppings, vegetables, cheese, and pizza seasoning.
What’s your take on toppings of Supreme Pizzas?
In your opinion, which pizzeria has the best Supreme Pizza topping combination?
Share your thoughts by commenting in the comments section below.
